That would give a comparison certainly, if done in 2 different cars as you suggest. But pointless, because when exactly do you, in your everyday life, travel a fixed distance at a fixed speed and then back again - except for doing a test like this. The figures quoted here by members are real life experinces in their own motors. If you want precise figures and a comparison between 2 cars look it up on the internet for the 2 cars you want to compare. This will give a far better comparison.
Not pointless at all but I think you miss the point. What I want is a repeatable test for my car so I know (a) in the future when something has become wrong with my car and (b) if something is wrong already compared to the same model car opwned by someone else. I am not interested in the figure for two different cars I am happy with my mig.
I see. Still not convinced by the theory though.
Point (a) - it is only you who will know that, by the fact the consumption changes dramatically. And any noises, rattles, bangs, whistles, drop in performance etc...
Point (b) - I see your point, but think that with all the variables that exist, just in the car (mileage, engine wear, extra weight, tyres, wheels, spoilers, valances, side skirts........), let alone climate (temperature, wind speed / direction) this kind of test is not really applicable to cars that are as old (and potentially worn) as the Omega. Yes, it can give you an idea for sure, as can motoring mags and online info, but from the point of view of knowing if there is something wrong .... you just gotta "feeeeeel it".
That said, if you did want a comparison against another members' car, you will need to give far more details of your car - not just engine size. And also receive the same details back from the other tester. A 2.6 with 180k on the clock is likely to differ in mpg to the same car with 50k on the clock.
Why not get a diagnostic check done and if all ok, note what fuel consumption you are getting and use that as a bench mark.
No offence meant, but I cannot see how such concise tests can be conducted on cars such as the Omega
Apologies for the essay