Some say that nostalgia is best left in the past, but I cut my teeth on valve circuits so this topic has given me a warm, cuddly feeling!
I do agree with your comments, though, especially concerning the unbalnced ratio between orders of harmonics. so we ARE on the same page, basically. Still in regard to the Quads, unless you spend that fortune that we don't have of top-notch transformers, I reluctantly admit that a decent MOSFET amplifier would win on transient response, which the ESLs would capitalise on.
Chris, I can only apologise that you feel left out; I used to teach Electronics, so I could start a fresh class for you? I dare not waste any more Forum time explaining harmonics, distortion, non-linearity and intermodulation products, all of which are factors affecting audio quality - please accept that good values in each of these parameters cost lots of beer vouchers to achieve!
Ron.