Omega Owners Forum

Chat Area => General Discussion Area => Topic started by: Varche on 31 May 2013, 16:09:24

Title: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: Varche on 31 May 2013, 16:09:24
I have an HP pc that is running quite nicely with the Vista Business that was already installed on it and it has a COA.

Mrs V's replacement HP machine will be here soon and that too has a COA for Vista Business on the casing but no operating system installed.

I have three possibilities. XP Home(Have disc and key) XP Pro (have disc and key) . Both are pre service pack 3 or put Vista on it. The last time I installed XP Pro from scratch I had a devils own job with all the updates.

If I go for the Vista option how do I go about cheaply getting the disc? I feel a little uneasy about not having a disc for my machine but maybe setting up an HP recovery partition and buying HP discs off the Internet would do the job. A few Ebay sellers at around £6 for the four.

Any advice appreciated.

Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: cem_devecioglu on 31 May 2013, 16:27:32
without doubt you will have a wide variety of answers :-\
 
xp pro would be adequate imo..
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: dbug on 31 May 2013, 16:28:30
I have an HP pc that is running quite nicely with the Vista Business that was already installed on it and it has a COA.

Mrs V's replacement HP machine will be here soon and that too has a COA for Vista Business on the casing but no operating system installed.

I have three possibilities. XP Home(Have disc and key) XP Pro (have disc and key) . Both are pre service pack 3 or put Vista on it. The last time I installed XP Pro from scratch I had a devils own job with all the updates.

If I go for the Vista option how do I go about cheaply getting the disc? I feel a little uneasy about not having a disc for my machine but maybe setting up an HP recovery partition and buying HP discs off the Internet would do the job. A few Ebay sellers at around £6 for the four.

Any advice appreciated.

At that price will be pirate ;)

If you're going to pay out for an o/s go for Win7 - try and get an oem copy ;)

Failing that no reason why XP Pro won't be OK - just make sure you install SP3.
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: Kevin Wood on 31 May 2013, 17:02:50
Anything except installing Vista will be a sensible answer. ;D
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: cnj on 31 May 2013, 18:53:29
as kevin says ,anything but vista. if you can get win 7 at a reasonable cost I would go for that in preference to win xp as support has just/nearly ended !
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: Varche on 31 May 2013, 18:57:21
What is wrong with Vista?
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: dbug on 31 May 2013, 22:15:26
What is wrong with Vista?

Basically its krap - needs high spec machine to cope with a very memory hungry, bloated o/s - else it runs slowly.  HTH ;)
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: TheBoy on 31 May 2013, 22:16:23
Kinda pointless putting XP on anything now, its out next March, so you need to move on from XP then anyway.

Nought wrong with Vista, but Win7 is a later evolution, and a fair bit more refined.

The COA keys may be disabled.
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: paul.lovejoy on 01 June 2013, 04:28:08
So is the best o/s windows 7 professional and what about explorer please, sorry Varche to ask on your post, but this seems to explain some issues i am having Thanks :y
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: Terbs on 01 June 2013, 10:00:12
Varche, I used to think XP Pro was the best thing since sliced bread. I was put off Vista by so many people I now have Windows 7 32bit and 64bit on my machine. Took a bit of getting used to, but now if I use a machine with XP on it, its like going back to the dark ages. :y
My machine is high (ish) spec, hence 64bit for me.....the 32bit disk is for when the grandchildren come over so they don't muck my stuff up !!!!!!!! ;D :y
32bit Ultimate would serve you well imo :y

Only bit I don't like is using Outlook for mail, and not Outlook Express. I expect the guru's will turn their noses up, but personally, I got on well with OE.
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: TheBoy on 01 June 2013, 10:12:02
So is the best o/s windows 7 professional and what about explorer please, sorry Varche to ask on your post, but this seems to explain some issues i am having Thanks :y
Without a touch enabled device, Windows 8 looks clunky. Sadly, it appears that Win 8.1, formally Blue, won't fair much better :(

So Windows 7 would be my preferred choice of OS now.  Hence virtually every PC (I have a few!) in the house runs it.

Given the cost difference between Win7 Home Premium and Win7 Pro, unless you need Pro (ie, bitlocker and proper domain integration - not needed by many home users), Home Premium makes more sense.

If the machine currently runs Vista, I probably wouldn't upgrade it unless I needed to. And to be honest, if it does, its likely to be 4 - 6 years old, so not really worth spending money on, when its about ready for the scrapheap.

If the machine currently runs XP, you need to consider moving away, as extended support ends in a few months (so no more security patches, which means, realistically, you are playing Russian Roulette plugging it into an Internet enabled network). Its pretty likely that a machine built in the XP era is going to need a hardware upgrade, as well as the licence to run Windows 7, so may not be viable.

For most people, anything that is Intel Core2 Duo or higher (ie, Core2 Duo/Quad, i3, i5, i7) and has 2Gb RAM should run Windows 7 well enough. Laptops may need to have the hard disk changed to an SSD to bump the speed up enough to be usable. Netbook owners have little choice to run Win7 - max out the RAM (2Gb for most Atoms) and SSD it, you'll still find it sluggish in the first couple of minutes of switching on.


As for browsers, thats personal choice. The only one of the big 3 I would passionately say avoid is Chrome, on security grounds.

Personally, I tend to use IE, as its updates are integrated into Windows Update, so its one less thing to remember to update. Firefox has some nice tools for web developers, but needs constant updating, at least weekly.

I find IE faster and stable than the others. Its reputation of instability comes from the fact it allows plugins (eg, Java, Flash, Acrobat, toolbars, search etc etc), and some of these are dire. The poor Firefox and Chrome people are just beginning to realise this. With all browsers, be picky about the add-ons you allow.  I honestly can't remember the last time I had IE crash, and I tend to use it all day, every day.
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: TheBoy on 01 June 2013, 10:24:00
I was put off Vista by so many people
Mostly spread about by the (sadly, poor) IT journalists we have, who think its "crap" based on the fact they "cannot be arsed to learn how to use it". Vista also suffered as it was a new kernel, so drivers were a bit slow to become available - much like the Windows 9x -> Windows 2000 step (hence MS introduced the sacrificial Me).

My machine is high (ish) spec, hence 64bit for me
64bit is only worthwhile if you have more than 4Gb RAM, and need to use all that RAM. That said, 64bit drivers are now mature, so 32bit doesn't have the advantage it did a couple of years back. 64bit Windows data structures are larger, so at 4Gb or less, it probably makes more sense to use 32bit (even though most 32bit installations can only "see" 3-3.5Gb of RAM

32bit Ultimate would serve you well imo :y
Not sure the OP would see the benefits over HomePrem (or Pro) to make the extra cost worthwhile, and Ultimate is quite expensive.

Only bit I don't like is using Outlook for mail, and not Outlook Express. I expect the guru's will turn their noses up, but personally, I got on well with OE.
Outlook (as in the full Office product) doesn't really work unless the mail server is Microsoft Exchange. Its POP3 and IMAP support is a bit weak, and certainly clunky.

I would strongly recommend people stick to OE (older Windows) or Windows Mail/Live Mail (newer Windows, but you have to download it) if you just want to use it with the mail services provided by your ISP. Obviously, other mail clients available, but like the browser in the post above, the MS variants are updated with Windows, so one less thing to worry about.
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: Terbs on 01 June 2013, 10:24:06
Blimey TB :o :o :o :o :o :o

Are you on some kind of pill ;D ;D ;D

That was a couple of very constructive posts !!!!!!!!! :y
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: TheBoy on 01 June 2013, 10:28:07
Blimey TB :o :o :o :o :o :o

Are you on some kind of pill ;D ;D ;D

That was a couple of very constructive posts !!!!!!!!! :y
I'm trying to put off configuring a new network switch  :-[
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: Terbs on 01 June 2013, 10:30:21
Not hijacking, probably help Varche.....

The other mail clients...can you still use your existing e-mail address ;)

Re-reading your post, I am assuming the answer is yes
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: Varche on 01 June 2013, 10:38:14
Hi

That is very helpful.

We aren't high end users with posh software suites. The fact that we are upgrading from old PC's to these fancy HP Duo core 3Ghz jobbies gives enough clues.

I have been using Vista for a few months and don't see any slowness. (3GB RAM) .

So If I want to do a clean install Vista Business on the other machine with its COA sticker and have peace of mind for mine(32bit), what Windows Disc do I actually need to buy (off Ebay or anywhere else) ?
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: TheBoy on 01 June 2013, 10:39:15
Not hijacking, probably help Varche.....

The other mail clients...can you still use your existing e-mail address ;)
Of course.

If you've set your Outlook up as POP3, by default this deletes mail off the server (it doesn't work too well if you set it not to delete), so any new mail client will not be able to see that mail you have downloaded. Which may be a problem if you need to keep some of the mail.

Windows Mail/Live Mail is very much like OE.
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: TheBoy on 01 June 2013, 10:51:19
Hi

That is very helpful.

We aren't high end users with posh software suites. The fact that we are upgrading from old PC's to these fancy HP Duo core 3Ghz jobbies gives enough clues.

I have been using Vista for a few months and don't see any slowness. (3GB RAM) .

So If I want to do a clean install Vista Business on the other machine with its COA sticker and have peace of mind for mine(32bit), what Windows Disc do I actually need to buy (off Ebay or anywhere else) ?
P4 based machines I guess.

You may find, as I eluded to earlier, that the COA sticker's key has been disabled. This started happening towards the end of the XP era, but different manaufacturers implemented this at different times.

You *may* find there is a recovery partition on disks, if it hasn't been pissed around with - although it is quite an old PC, it may have been from the era that HP made you stick in DVDRs a day or so after starting it up for the first time. You need to look  :'(


If you need to get a Vista disk - not legally available on its own - as I suspect the COA key is disabled, I think you may have to buy a full one :(, which isn't really worth doing (looking in region of £70+).  Being P4, I wouldn't like to say if Win 7 (same price) would run well on it...  ...I have a couple of Dell P4's piled up here that I need to take to the dump, I suppose I could try it if they have enough memory in.

Either way, if you use a generic disk, you will still have fun and games with drivers, not to mention all the updates (lots in 6 years ;D). I hope your internet is good ;D


What is the spec of the "new" machines - CPU and RAM. Also the precise model number.  Once I have these, I may be able to advise the best course of action.
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: TheBoy on 01 June 2013, 10:51:50
Varche - do they have any OS on them at all?
Title: Re: Computer operating system enquiry Vista or XP
Post by: Varche on 01 June 2013, 12:12:44
Varche - do they have any OS on them at all?

HP dc5800 microtowers. core duo 2.66 Ghz 3Gb Ram. Sata 240 GB HDD. * running Vista currently (purchased S/H already loaded with COA on PC case).

HP dc5800 micro tower  core duo 3.00 Ghz 4Gb Ram SATA HDD. No operating system but has COA on PC case apparently

* Can't see a recovery partition on that drive but maybe that is just me!

The old PC's were P4's and are now dead. I have saved the IDE HDD's and have a USB caddy to make them useable.

How can you tell if a COA has been disabled? Is there a list somewhere for us humans?