Omega Owners Forum

Chat Area => General Discussion Area => Topic started by: Marks DTM Calib on 06 October 2008, 08:52:15

Title: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 06 October 2008, 08:52:15
Ok, so we keep hearing how the Prius is going to save the planet and all that nonsense!

But, what is it that makes the Prius more efficient.....your thoughts please before I put you all out of your misery!
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Jimbob on 06 October 2008, 08:55:08
erm, it isnt?
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 06 October 2008, 08:56:19
Quote
erm, it isnt?


Well actually its mpg is not bad at all.....
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Welung666 on 06 October 2008, 08:57:21
£35 a year road tax too :y Still wouldn't buy one tho, can't stand small cars  ;D
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Martin_1962 on 06 October 2008, 08:57:27
Thirstier than a similar sized Diesel car, massive pollution problems from the battery manufacture, disposal problems of same batteries.
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Jay w on 06 October 2008, 08:57:35
i can't see it myself.....

the car has a potential disposal issue, batteries generally have a slightly acidic nature to them for starters.

the whole build and shipping worries me as well.......so lets build a car that has lots of/one huge great big battery, then shove it on a container ship and shove it half way round the world, thus causing more pollution.....but this is a eco friendly car so that makes it all OK (NOT)

Personally i think it is marketing hype, i am not entirely convinced of global warming being as a direct result of CO emmissions

Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 06 October 2008, 08:58:13
Just a note to all here.....as stated above....we are talking about efficient  :y
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Jay w on 06 October 2008, 09:01:45
Quote
Just a note to all here.....as stated above....we are talking about efficient  :y

that's me knackered then  :(
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 06 October 2008, 09:02:28
Quote
Quote
Just a note to all here.....as stated above....we are talking about efficient  :y

that's me knackered then  :(


Its a key thing.....and explains why it NEEDS to be a hybrid!
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Mr Skrunts on 06 October 2008, 09:07:14
Quote
Just a note to all here.....as stated above....we are talking about efficient  :y

Are you thinking of buying one Mark ::)

It's not made by Sony so it might not be on TB's gay list.. ;D ;D

On the effiency side I have no idea at all, all I know is that a lot of Hollywood stars own one to look and sound good in interviews but then drive round in thier 5.0 Mustang's.  :-/ :-/
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Entwood on 06 October 2008, 09:07:35
The biggest "inefficiency" in the internal combustion engine is the wasted energy in the form of exhaust heat, further inefficiencies for the car itself are things like brake heat.

AFAIK know the prius hybrid idea is to reduce these wastes as far as possible, so the electric side produces little waste heat, and the electric braking turns the kinetic energy back to electrics instead of heat ??

but as I know very little about the prius .. other than its a marketing hype .. I'm just guessing
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 06 October 2008, 09:09:32
A hint....from the engine theory

         Opening the inlet valve
Earlier Later
More power at higher rpm Less power
 
More overlap with exhaust valve     More torque at lower rpm  
Lower flexibility Better emissions!
Poorer response at low rpm


         Closing the inlet valve
Earlier Later
Less power  More power at higher rpm
 
Higher compression ratio at low rpm     Compression ratio improves with higher rpm  
Better torque max. torque in higher rpm band  
More flexible engine


         Opening the exhaust valve
Earlier Later
Less pumping losses, bit more power  More pumping losses,less power
Hotter outlet valve    More complete combustion, less emissions  
More chance of pre-ignition   Lower exhaust temperature!


         Closing the exhaust valve
Earlier Later
Less overlap with inlet valve Part of intake mixture goes straight into exhaust at lower rpm (engine is "Off cam")
 
More flexible engine at low rpm
 
More high end power
Less power at higher rpm Less flexible engine at low rpm  
More torque at low rpm  Low torque at lower rpm  
Improved emissions  
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Andy B on 06 October 2008, 09:09:33
Quote
Quote
erm, it isnt?


Well actually its mpg is not bad at all.....

Depends how you drive it.  OK the Top Gear skewed the 'test' but I thought the result was quite interesting.

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=N8XDscWleKw


Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: TheBoy on 06 October 2008, 09:10:43
Mr DTM, am I allowed to answer  :-X
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 06 October 2008, 09:18:10
The answer is already above....highlighted!

So I guess so!
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: TheBoy on 06 October 2008, 09:19:41
Quote
The answer is already above....highlighted!

So I guess so!
Ah, I think we posted at same time!
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 06 October 2008, 09:22:44
The answer is its the petrol engine setup that gives it the efficiency!

The Prius does not have an Otto cycle engine, it has something closer to the Atkinson cycle with valve timing etc skewed towards max efficiency as per the highlighted fields above.

Trouble is that such an engine is rather horrible to drive so they have to bolt an electric motor setup on it to make it useable and over come its poor standard operating conditions.

The choice of cycle also explains why its shite on a track for economy as your now operating in the upper revs where it has no go!
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: tunnie on 06 October 2008, 09:39:29
plus the engine is hidden under all the electrical gubbins, no independant garage will touch them, dealers only.

Spark plug replacments (every 60k) the engine has to be removed to do this..... from underneath!

It means you have to drive to a main dealer, my closest would be Oxford, whats environmentally friendly about driving 30 miles to a dealer, when there is a local garage 1/2 mile away?
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: TheBoy on 06 October 2008, 09:41:28
Quote
The answer is its the petrol engine setup that gives it the efficiency!

The Prius does not have an Otto cycle engine, it has something closer to the Atkinson cycle with valve timing etc skewed towards max efficiency as per the highlighted fields above.

Trouble is that such an engine is rather horrible to drive so they have to bolt an electric motor setup on it to make it useable and over come its poor standard operating conditions.

The choice of cycle also explains why its shite on a track for economy as your now operating in the upper revs where it has no go!
Added to that, surely all the battery charging is seriously going to hurt economy anyway, thus raising emissions in reality (even though not raising on the standard tests)?
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 06 October 2008, 09:55:37
Quote
Quote
The answer is its the petrol engine setup that gives it the efficiency!

The Prius does not have an Otto cycle engine, it has something closer to the Atkinson cycle with valve timing etc skewed towards max efficiency as per the highlighted fields above.

Trouble is that such an engine is rather horrible to drive so they have to bolt an electric motor setup on it to make it useable and over come its poor standard operating conditions.

The choice of cycle also explains why its shite on a track for economy as your now operating in the upper revs where it has no go!
Added to that, surely all the battery charging is seriously going to hurt economy anyway, thus raising emissions in reality (even though not raising on the standard tests)?


Battery charges at 'opportune' moments...i.e. when cruising and to a lesser extent, under braking (regenerative). Clearly that spent enegry for charging is recovere when the motor is running (round town and accelerating).

But, as stated, we are discussing the reason behind the efficiency here.....rather hoped somebody might pick straight up on it following the engine threads but, it still highlights the theory and consequences of operating at one extreme of valve timing!  :y
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: TheBoy on 06 October 2008, 10:00:00
Quote
Quote
Quote
The answer is its the petrol engine setup that gives it the efficiency!

The Prius does not have an Otto cycle engine, it has something closer to the Atkinson cycle with valve timing etc skewed towards max efficiency as per the highlighted fields above.

Trouble is that such an engine is rather horrible to drive so they have to bolt an electric motor setup on it to make it useable and over come its poor standard operating conditions.

The choice of cycle also explains why its shite on a track for economy as your now operating in the upper revs where it has no go!
Added to that, surely all the battery charging is seriously going to hurt economy anyway, thus raising emissions in reality (even though not raising on the standard tests)?


Battery charges at 'opportune' moments...i.e. when cruising and to a lesser extent, under braking (regenerative). Clearly that spent enegry for charging is recovere when the motor is running (round town and accelerating).

But, as stated, we are discussing the reason behind the efficiency here.....rather hoped somebody might pick straight up on it following the engine threads but, it still highlights the theory and consequences of operating at one extreme of valve timing!  :y
I real world, is it that much more efficient (purely on day to day mpg) than a similar sized car (Focus/Astra)?
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 06 October 2008, 10:01:20
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
The answer is its the petrol engine setup that gives it the efficiency!

The Prius does not have an Otto cycle engine, it has something closer to the Atkinson cycle with valve timing etc skewed towards max efficiency as per the highlighted fields above.

Trouble is that such an engine is rather horrible to drive so they have to bolt an electric motor setup on it to make it useable and over come its poor standard operating conditions.

The choice of cycle also explains why its shite on a track for economy as your now operating in the upper revs where it has no go!
Added to that, surely all the battery charging is seriously going to hurt economy anyway, thus raising emissions in reality (even though not raising on the standard tests)?


Battery charges at 'opportune' moments...i.e. when cruising and to a lesser extent, under braking (regenerative). Clearly that spent enegry for charging is recovere when the motor is running (round town and accelerating).

But, as stated, we are discussing the reason behind the efficiency here.....rather hoped somebody might pick straight up on it following the engine threads but, it still highlights the theory and consequences of operating at one extreme of valve timing!  :y
I real world, is it that much more efficient (purely on day to day mpg) than a similar sized car (Focus/Astra)?


Yes because the engine can be optimised for efficiency!
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: TheBoy on 06 October 2008, 10:01:54
Quote
Quote
Quote
The answer is its the petrol engine setup that gives it the efficiency!

The Prius does not have an Otto cycle engine, it has something closer to the Atkinson cycle with valve timing etc skewed towards max efficiency as per the highlighted fields above.

Trouble is that such an engine is rather horrible to drive so they have to bolt an electric motor setup on it to make it useable and over come its poor standard operating conditions.

The choice of cycle also explains why its shite on a track for economy as your now operating in the upper revs where it has no go!
Added to that, surely all the battery charging is seriously going to hurt economy anyway, thus raising emissions in reality (even though not raising on the standard tests)?


Battery charges at 'opportune' moments...i.e. when cruising and to a lesser extent, under braking (regenerative). Clearly that spent enegry for charging is recovere when the motor is running (round town and accelerating).

But, as stated, we are discussing the reason behind the efficiency here.....rather hoped somebody might pick straight up on it following the engine threads but, it still highlights the theory and consequences of operating at one extreme of valve timing!  :y
I did, but only because you prompted me, so I went and looked over the timings  :-[
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: TheBoy on 06 October 2008, 10:04:24
Quote
Yes because the engine can be optimised for efficiency!
Real world, Prius is around mid 40s.  I would have thought that a 1.4 Focus/Astra should be achieving near that anyway without lugging all that heavy metal about?

I know our loan Rover 414 we had for ages a while ago managed high 30s day to day.
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: cem_devecioglu on 06 October 2008, 10:07:13
Quote
Quote
Yes because the engine can be optimised for efficiency!
Real world, Prius is around mid 40s.  I would have thought that a 1.4 Focus/Astra should be achieving near that anyway without lugging all that heavy metal about?
I know our loan Rover 414 we had for ages a while ago managed high 30s day to day.

Agreed..and you dont need to pay for 2 engines initially and maintenance for 2 engines..  Means 2X trouble in my dictionary ;D
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: cem_devecioglu on 06 October 2008, 10:08:10
Use 2 cars instead and pay 2x tx and insurance ;D ;D ;D :-[
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Martin_1962 on 06 October 2008, 10:58:18
I knew it had a different cycle - ie it actually pumps the inlet air back out to raise efficiency.

Horrid engine though.

Rather have an M3 - more economical when driven normally
Title: Re: Discussion point.........The Prius
Post by: Kevin Wood on 06 October 2008, 11:17:03
Quote
Real world, Prius is around mid 40s.  I would have thought that a 1.4 Focus/Astra should be achieving near that anyway without lugging all that heavy metal about?

I had a ride in a Prius last week. An Italian Taxi driven by an Italian Taxi driver in an Italian city (Milan). That scenario gets me thinking sub-20 MPG whatever the car. From what I could tell from the horrendously complex MID equivalent and the metric fuel consumption display it was averaging 60MPG. :o He wasn't hanging about with us on board and the average wasn't dropping. This was urban driving in its extreme. TLGP followed by heavy breaking for the next set of lights for 15 miles or more.

I guess in addition to the tune of the engine, when the engine is running, it doesn't need to run lightly loaded because unwanted power can be belted back into the battery, meaning the engine never runs in an inefficient, heavily-throttled-back state. It's either heavily loaded (by the car and / or the battery) or stopped.

I'd like to see what happens on a long motorway cruise. In a city, it'll always have the ability to pump energy into the battery, and use it again, because of the nature of the driving. On a motorway cruise that's fast enough that the electric motor can't sustain it, I can't see any option but for the engine to run lightly-loaded once the battery can accept no more charge. Maybe the more efficient tune of the engine will still give a significant gain over a normal petrol car. Maybe not. :-/

It's an interesting idea, but I'd want to know what a liability they are when they reach middle-age before buying one.

Kevin