Omega Owners Forum

Chat Area => General Discussion Area => Topic started by: kris9128 on 20 November 2008, 21:52:29

Title: waters vs gilmour
Post by: kris9128 on 20 November 2008, 21:52:29

just wondering what people think. who is the better performer. roger waters or david gilmour. having seen waters live in concert twice but only listening to gilmour on cd/dvd i would have to say waters was by far the better performer. have just watched gilmour live in gadansk. sounded and looked liked a karioke contest. not saying gilmour isnt talented ( with instruments) just voaclly challenged. whereas waters seems to cover all bases.
just wondering what you all think.

Title: Re: waters vs gilmour
Post by: albitz on 20 November 2008, 22:01:31

I have also seen Waters and thought he was brilliant,havent seen Gilmour live but I do love his guitar playing.
From what I have seen of his live DVD,s,I dont think he has the charisma as a performer that Waters has.  :-/
EDIT - Shame the ego,s got in the way, when they were together they were brilliant. 8-)