Omega Owners Forum

Chat Area => General Discussion Area => Topic started by: Varche on 30 December 2008, 15:04:12

Title: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: Varche on 30 December 2008, 15:04:12
http://news.uk.msn.com/uk/article.aspx?cp-documentid=12328943

What do you think? Good idea or just another money spinner.?

It maybe part of harmonising the situation across the EU. In Spain you have to have a medical at 50 and then every five years (I think) after that in order to keep a licence. The medical costs between 18 euros and 40 euros depending on where you go.

El Varche
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: Richie London on 30 December 2008, 15:10:04
looks like they are coming out with a few ideas to make money lately.
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: STMO123 on 30 December 2008, 16:07:59
Depends what kind of health test it is. For instance, if I was allowed to say to the examiner 'I'll give you a 5 metre start and, if I catch you, I'm allowed to punch you in the face', then I reckon I'd pass.
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: LaserLance on 30 December 2008, 16:49:11
Any HGV/PSV after 45 has to have a health checkup for his licence every 5 years and it costs whatever your doctor wants to charge :'( :'( :'( my last one cost me £65 but if my company were paying it would have been £120 ......  :o :o :o
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: Jay w on 30 December 2008, 17:00:10
personally i think it is an excellent idea, i think it should be compulsory as well.

It would go a long way to reducing the amount of people who are not fit for the road, well in theory it would anyway.
The sad reality is someone would turn it into a money spinner by offering to take the test on behalf of someone who quite clearly wouldn't pass.

i would go so far as to say i think driving should be retested every 10/15 years as well.

I also believe that anyone getting behind the wheel of a car should have lessons on the motorway and also be taught the art of car control, very much like sweden, in addition they should be taught basic mantainence as well

i know it wouldn't make me popular but i believe it would improve the standards we have on the road today
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: Andy B on 30 December 2008, 17:05:57
Quote
...... in addition they should be taught basic mantainence as well ......


You're expected to be able to identify various parts from under the bonnet for your driving test now. How that helps you to be a good driver I'll never ever know .....  :-/ If you're no good with tools at the side of the road, buy an AA/RAC/etc card  :y
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: Jay w on 30 December 2008, 17:08:23
Quote
Quote
...... in addition they should be taught basic mantainence as well ......


You're expected to be able to identify various parts from under the bonnet for your driving test now. How that helps you to be a good driver I'll never ever know .....  :-/ If you're no good with tools at the side of the road, buy an AA/RAC/etc card  :y

i'm talking about being able to change a tyre and identify when a tyre is illegal that sort of stuff
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: waspy on 30 December 2008, 17:46:42
A medicals a good idea if it's implemented properly.
For what it's worth evrey driver should take a re-test every 10 years, not a proper first time test, because hey we'd all fail that, but a basic one. I saw a guy in the local car park the other day & the way he drove, he'd never pass.
This would cut the accidents down by alot, but i guess they wouldn't make enough money outa it >:( >:( >:( COKS, all of them.
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: Jay w on 30 December 2008, 18:07:45
Quote
A medicals a good idea if it's implemented properly.
For what it's worth evrey driver should take a re-test every 10 years, not a proper first time test, because hey we'd all fail that, but a basic one. I saw a guy in the local car park the other day & the way he drove, he'd never pass.
This would cut the accidents down by alot, but i guess they wouldn't make enough money outa it >:( >:( >:( COKS, all of them.

i disagree, a full on first time test......theory and all

why do anything less? to do so would seem pointlees and devalue to purpose of improving driving standard....

It's no different to going to night school 10 years after doing your GCSE's and retaking them, but an easier test this time, seems a waste of time

Currently as a driver it is MY responsibility to keep myself up to date on the changes in driving law, like hell do it, and i would imagine there are many like me, so the full on malarkey will ensure i have
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: Ian_D on 30 December 2008, 18:21:42
Quote
Quote
A medicals a good idea if it's implemented properly.
For what it's worth evrey driver should take a re-test every 10 years, not a proper first time test, because hey we'd all fail that, but a basic one. I saw a guy in the local car park the other day & the way he drove, he'd never pass.
This would cut the accidents down by alot, but i guess they wouldn't make enough money outa it >:( >:( >:( COKS, all of them.

i disagree, a full on first time test......theory and all

why do anything less? to do so would seem pointlees and devalue to purpose of improving driving standard....

It's no different to going to night school 10 years after doing your GCSE's and retaking them, but an easier test this time, seems a waste of time

Currently as a driver it is MY responsibility to keep myself up to date on the changes in driving law, like hell do it, and i would imagine there are many like me, so the full on malarkey will ensure i have

I think a lot of people would be surprised how hard the test can be...

I for one would have to try hard if I had to meet the standards (and I took my test 3 years ago).

Its the silly little things like driving with only one hand on the wheel, or using palm of your hand on the wheel when turning round etc.

Plus how would you do a retest? I passed in a manual, and now drive an auto, so would that mean that if I did a retest in my own car I could only drive autos... Think it would open up a big can of worms tbh!
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: gsdtrainer on 30 December 2008, 18:35:39
Quote
Quote
Quote
A medicals a good idea if it's implemented properly.
For what it's worth evrey driver should take a re-test every 10 years, not a proper first time test, because hey we'd all fail that, but a basic one. I saw a guy in the local car park the other day & the way he drove, he'd never pass.
This would cut the accidents down by alot, but i guess they wouldn't make enough money outa it >:( >:( >:( COKS, all of them.

i disagree, a full on first time test......theory and all

why do anything less? to do so would seem pointlees and devalue to purpose of improving driving standard....

It's no different to going to night school 10 years after doing your GCSE's and retaking them, but an easier test this time, seems a waste of time

Currently as a driver it is MY responsibility to keep myself up to date on the changes in driving law, like hell do it, and i would imagine there are many like me, so the full on malarkey will ensure i have

I think a lot of people would be surprised how hard the test can be...

I for one would have to try hard if I had to meet the standards (and I took my test 3 years ago).

Its the silly little things like driving with only one hand on the wheel, or using palm of your hand on the wheel when turning round etc.

Plus how would you do a retest? I passed in a manual, and now drive an auto, so would that mean that if I did a retest in my own car I could only drive autos... Think it would open up a big can of worms tbh!
Just a boy.I took mine 44yrs ago,how would it be for us old fogies ::) ::) ::) ::)We had to do hand signals as well ;)
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: Jay w on 30 December 2008, 18:45:29
i did mine 20 years ago and i know i would fail if i had to re-take it today.

But i have a feeling it might make me a better driver if i was forced into doing it
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: STMO123 on 30 December 2008, 18:47:53
Quote
i did mine 20 years ago and i know i would fail if i had to re-take it today.

But i have a feeling it might make me a better driver if i was forced into doing it

I think you probably drive quite well as you are Jay. We DO NOT want the highways full of.......oh, I dont know......say.......people like AA ;D
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: Jay w on 30 December 2008, 18:49:34
Quote
Quote
i did mine 20 years ago and i know i would fail if i had to re-take it today.

But i have a feeling it might make me a better driver if i was forced into doing it

I think you probably drive quite well as you are Jay. We DO NOT want the highways full of.......oh, I dont know......say.......people like AA ;D

AA's my hero  :y
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: waspy on 30 December 2008, 19:00:18
Quote
i did mine 20 years ago and i know i would fail if i had to re-take it today.

But i have a feeling it might make me a better driver if i was forced into doing it

I disagree, not about it making you a better driver, but as a whole, drivers gain from experience & not from taking a re-test. As i said it should be classed on your ability to drive.
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: ngrainqey on 30 December 2008, 19:06:34
Quote
A medicals a good idea if it's implemented properly.
For what it's worth evrey driver should take a re-test every 10 years, not a proper first time test, because hey we'd all fail that, but a basic one. I saw a guy in the local car park the other day & the way he drove, he'd never pass.
This would cut the accidents down by alot, but i guess they wouldn't make enough money outa it >:( >:( >:( COKS, all of them.

i have to say that i agree, i dont think they should make it easier but more like be less strict eg... who uses push pull steering for example all the time? as soon as you pass your test if your not a moron you use common sense like when you dont NEED to indicate because there's nobody to indicate to or like instead of the 3. turn just pull into a driveway to help get round alot easier or go to a roundabout for example if its there
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: Kieran on 30 December 2008, 19:07:19
I had my licence when i was 15yrs old (in NZ) :o, no way would i pass a test now.
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: Lizzie_Zoom on 30 December 2008, 19:11:38
I think the good thing about these proposals, more than testing the individuals skills and ability of driving a motor vehicle, is that it is about their health being reviewed.

I often wonder how many drivers have poor eye sight (I know of two!) or suffer from unknown medical conditions that could cause a fatal accident, but still go on driving regardless without check up? :-? :-?

This new system would weed out those technically dangerous drivers. 8-) 8-)
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: Andy B on 30 December 2008, 19:14:19
Quote
.....
 because hey we'd all fail that ......

Speak for yourself!  ;)  ;D  ;D  :y  :y  :y
The closest to a restest I've done recently was a speed awareness course .....  :-X You'd to drive without crossing arms on the wheel, keep to speed limits etc etc. Not a driving test as we know but most of the major things you'd need to comply with when on a test.
I had my wrists slapped for driving an auto with 2 feet!!  :-?  :y
Title: Re: 10 year health test for drivers?
Post by: Ian_D on 31 December 2008, 01:51:21
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
A medicals a good idea if it's implemented properly.
For what it's worth evrey driver should take a re-test every 10 years, not a proper first time test, because hey we'd all fail that, but a basic one. I saw a guy in the local car park the other day & the way he drove, he'd never pass.
This would cut the accidents down by alot, but i guess they wouldn't make enough money outa it >:( >:( >:( COKS, all of them.

i disagree, a full on first time test......theory and all

why do anything less? to do so would seem pointlees and devalue to purpose of improving driving standard....

It's no different to going to night school 10 years after doing your GCSE's and retaking them, but an easier test this time, seems a waste of time

Currently as a driver it is MY responsibility to keep myself up to date on the changes in driving law, like hell do it, and i would imagine there are many like me, so the full on malarkey will ensure i have

I think a lot of people would be surprised how hard the test can be...

I for one would have to try hard if I had to meet the standards (and I took my test 3 years ago).

Its the silly little things like driving with only one hand on the wheel, or using palm of your hand on the wheel when turning round etc.

Plus how would you do a retest? I passed in a manual, and now drive an auto, so would that mean that if I did a retest in my own car I could only drive autos... Think it would open up a big can of worms tbh!
Just a boy.I took mine 44yrs ago,how would it be for us old fogies ::) ::) ::) ::)We had to do hand signals as well ;)

My driving instructor made me do them.... God I felt like a right prat! Got so many strange looks  :-[ :-X

Really.. Is there any need???? If my indicators dont work, and its snowing (which it was on the day he made me do it), im hardly going to open the windows and wave my arms about like im having some sort of fit am i?  :P