Omega Owners Forum

Chat Area => General Discussion Area => Topic started by: Marks DTM Calib on 23 February 2009, 19:57:29

Title: Which would you choose
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 23 February 2009, 19:57:29
Option 1

(http://i11.ebayimg.com/04/i/001/34/ab/74f7_3.JPG)

Option 2

(http://i3.ebayimg.com/01/m/000/a4/e4/3ed0_12.JPG)
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: nick v6 on 23 February 2009, 19:59:11
i like the wheels on the escort :y
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 23 February 2009, 19:59:26
Ow yes, you need to overlook the fact that one of them has a shite engine, shite reliability, shite looks, crap interior that falls apart and a tendancy to rot
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 23 February 2009, 20:00:44
Quote
i like the wheels on the escort :y


Not standard fit so not part of what should be considered.

I would of used a different pic but, its impossible to find a photo of one in standard out of the factory state
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Richie London on 23 February 2009, 20:02:06
i like that saab, looks nice  :y :y
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Lizzie_Zoom on 23 February 2009, 20:02:30
Saab any day! :D :D ;)
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: nick v6 on 23 February 2009, 20:05:47
everyone will choose the saab
you should of done a compare between a escort cab and something like a pug cab
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: tunnie on 23 February 2009, 20:06:40
err neither. i would rather walk
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Omega man 2 on 23 February 2009, 20:06:46
Defo the saab :y
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: HolyCount on 23 February 2009, 20:07:20
Saab everytime  :y
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 23 February 2009, 20:08:19
Quote
everyone will choose the saab
you should of done a compare between a escort cab and something like a pug cab


No, I am compring cars which can be obtained for like for like prices....

One of the above is a proper convertible, the other is a standard car with the roof cut off, inferior chassis support plates welded on and handling that is worse than the average performing car which it was derived from.
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: immx on 23 February 2009, 20:09:00
I've had a mk6 escort cabro and It was very good. I bought it at 24,000 miles and sold it at 132,000 and in all that time it only broke down twice, once it needed a new battery and the other a new lead on the starter motor.

BUT .... I voted for the Saab cos if I nearly bought a hard top one before the miggy came up.

Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Elite Pete on 23 February 2009, 20:09:10
Depends how much I had to spend :)
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: tunnie on 23 February 2009, 20:09:28
Quote
Quote
everyone will choose the saab
you should of done a compare between a escort cab and something like a pug cab


No, I am compring cars which can be obtained for like for like prices....

One of the above is a proper convertible, the other is a standard car with the roof cut off, inferior chassis support plates welded on and handling that is worse than the average performing car which it was derived from.

Which is the Saab...
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: vauxfan2k on 23 February 2009, 20:09:56
Saab of course, Im suprised that there is any comparison  ;D
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: TheBoy on 23 February 2009, 20:10:46
Its a no brainer for me, but based on nothing more than the fact every escort I have ever driven, I've crashed.

No desire to look like a woman, I'll have a car with a tin roof.
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: nick v6 on 23 February 2009, 20:11:07
Quote
Depends how much I had to spend :)

you can't vote pete
mx5 not on the list :y
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: CaptainZok on 23 February 2009, 20:11:56
Quote
Quote
i like the wheels on the escort :y


Not standard fit so not part of what should be considered.

I would of used a different pic but, its impossible to find a photo of one in standard out of the factory state
Voila. (http://www.minidigger-hire.co.uk/images/skip.gif)
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Del Boy on 23 February 2009, 20:12:00
Saab any day but I don't really like the saab either  :-/
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 23 February 2009, 20:12:05
Quote
Depends how much I had to spend :)


Both go for the same cash when running (and not running interestingl!)
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: TheBoy on 23 February 2009, 20:12:44
Quote
Its a no brainer for me, but based on nothing more than the fact every escort I have ever driven, I've crashed.

No desire to look like a woman, I'll have a car with a tin roof.
Though I wouldn't have the saab either, never liked them.

If I HAD to have one I'd be torn  :-/

Probably go for the Ford - better resale value I reckon
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: nick v6 on 23 February 2009, 20:13:27
Quote
Quote
Depends how much I had to spend :)


Both go for the same cash when running (and not running interestingl!)

which one is cheapest to run :-?
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 23 February 2009, 20:13:44
Quote
Quote
Quote
i like the wheels on the escort :y


Not standard fit so not part of what should be considered.

I would of used a different pic but, its impossible to find a photo of one in standard out of the factory state
Voila. (http://www.minidigger-hire.co.uk/images/skip.gif)

PMSL
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 23 February 2009, 20:14:03
Quote
Quote
Quote
Depends how much I had to spend :)


Both go for the same cash when running (and not running interestingl!)


which one is cheapest to run :-?

Pretty much bugger all in that either!
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Elite Pete on 23 February 2009, 20:15:02
Quote
Quote
Depends how much I had to spend :)


Both go for the same cash when running (and not running interestingl!)
I don't think you would get a Saab for the price LK paid for the Escort which has a current MOT but the roof is a little tatty ;)

Although I must add he has just bought a Saab with a tin roof for less than he paid for the Escort ;D
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: TheBoy on 23 February 2009, 20:15:32
Quote
Quote
Its a no brainer for me, but based on nothing more than the fact every escort I have ever driven, I've crashed.

No desire to look like a woman, I'll have a car with a tin roof.
Though I wouldn't have the saab either, never liked them.

If I HAD to have one I'd be torn  :-/

Probably go for the Ford - better resale value I reckon
Nah, would have to be the saab - on the law of averages, I'm gonna mame myself next time I drive an Escort/Focus...
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 23 February 2009, 20:18:50
Quote
Quote
Quote
Depends how much I had to spend :)


Both go for the same cash when running (and not running interestingl!)
I don't think you would get a Saab for the price LK paid for the Escort which has a current MOT but the roof is a little tatty ;)

Although I must add he has just bought a Saab with a tin roof for less than he paid for the Escort ;D

Really....

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/1995-Saab-900-SE-2-3-Convertible-AUTO-spares-or-repair_W0QQitemZ150327990383QQcmdZViewItemQQptZAutomobiles_UK?hash=item150327990383&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14&_trkparms=66%3A2%7C65%3A7%7C39%3A1%7C240%3A1318

And its 2 years newer
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: TheBoy on 23 February 2009, 20:19:01
Can I have an old Skoda Estelle instead?
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: tyreburner on 23 February 2009, 20:19:39
Rover 600ti with a tin top  ;D :y
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: TheBoy on 23 February 2009, 20:20:10
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Depends how much I had to spend :)


Both go for the same cash when running (and not running interestingl!)
I don't think you would get a Saab for the price LK paid for the Escort which has a current MOT but the roof is a little tatty ;)

Although I must add he has just bought a Saab with a tin roof for less than he paid for the Escort ;D

Really....

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/1995-Saab-900-SE-2-3-Convertible-AUTO-spares-or-repair_W0QQitemZ150327990383QQcmdZViewItemQQptZAutomobiles_UK?hash=item150327990383&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14&_trkparms=66%3A2%7C65%3A7%7C39%3A1%7C240%3A1318

And its 2 years newer
shagged engine by all acounts though...
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 23 February 2009, 20:21:16
Shagged/no roof on LooKnees.....
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Elite Pete on 23 February 2009, 20:21:44
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Depends how much I had to spend :)


Both go for the same cash when running (and not running interestingl!)
I don't think you would get a Saab for the price LK paid for the Escort which has a current MOT but the roof is a little tatty ;)

Although I must add he has just bought a Saab with a tin roof for less than he paid for the Escort ;D

Really....

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/1995-Saab-900-SE-2-3-Convertible-AUTO-spares-or-repair_W0QQitemZ150327990383QQcmdZViewItemQQptZAutomobiles_UK?hash=item150327990383&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14&_trkparms=66%3A2%7C65%3A7%7C39%3A1%7C240%3A1318

And its 2 years newer
Loo-Knees is road legal apart from RFL and running, the Saab needs a good few quid throwing at it ::)
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 23 February 2009, 20:22:54
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Depends how much I had to spend :)



Both go for the same cash when running (and not running interestingl!)
I don't think you would get a Saab for the price LK paid for the Escort which has a current MOT but the roof is a little tatty ;)

Although I must add he has just bought a Saab with a tin roof for less than he paid for the Escort ;D

Really....

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/1995-Saab-900-SE-2-3-Convertible-AUTO-spares-or-repair_W0QQitemZ150327990383QQcmdZViewItemQQptZAutomobiles_UK?hash=item150327990383&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14&_trkparms=66%3A2%7C65%3A7%7C39%3A1%7C240%3A1318

And its 2 years newer
Loo-Knees is road legal apart from RFL and running, the Saab needs a good few quid throwing at it ::)


Second hand engine for 1-200 quid, 4-5 hours fitting and a re-sale price of a grand


Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Elite Pete on 23 February 2009, 20:23:02
Quote
Shagged/no roof on LooKnees.....
Its got a bit of a tear in each corner behind the rear windows which is quite common I believe.
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Martin_1962 on 23 February 2009, 20:23:48
Er they are both wrong wheel drive.

Last Saab I drove was horrid - the 4 year old 2.6 Omega I drove same day was 1000x better

The only Escrap of them model I have been in and driven was a van and it was dire.

Can I have a late 24V GSi3000 Carlton instead please?

Or a late Avenger or Sunbeam with fun bits (minimum 1600)?
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: nick v6 on 23 February 2009, 20:24:43
ann's sitting watching her programs but just looked over my sholder and said she would pick the escort as it looks nicer
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Richie London on 23 February 2009, 20:25:37
ive always looked at them escorts as womens cars. never wanted to drive one. i did drive a fiat pansy for 2 weeks. pile of poo that was  ;D ;D
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: stuart30 on 23 February 2009, 20:25:47
Hmmm i must be double sad...ive had an escort cabbie....looked nice,handled ok although very hard ride being it was lowered.

I do like the look of the Saab...in fact id happily have one. :y
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: nick v6 on 23 February 2009, 20:27:36
i'll have a 3 wheeler
elite pete know's how quick there are
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 23 February 2009, 20:27:44
Quote
ann's sitting watching her programs but just looked over my sholder and said she would pick the escort as it looks nicer


Essex based doris thinking dont count.... ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: nick v6 on 23 February 2009, 20:28:41
Quote
Quote
ann's sitting watching her programs but just looked over my sholder and said she would pick the escort as it looks nicer


Essex based doris thinking dont count.... ;D ;D ;D

whats that mean??? :-?
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 23 February 2009, 20:29:41
Quote
Quote
Quote
ann's sitting watching her programs but just looked over my sholder and said she would pick the escort as it looks nicer


Essex based doris thinking dont count.... ;D ;D ;D

whats that mean??? :-?


= a woman thinking in an essex girls way  ;D ;D ;D :y :y
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Welung666 on 23 February 2009, 20:33:39
Can we have an 'I'd rather walk' option please?
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Martin_1962 on 23 February 2009, 20:34:28
Quote
i'll have a 3 wheeler
elite pete know's how quick there are


Hayabusa Bond Bug or V8 Reliant Rialto?
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: tyreburner on 23 February 2009, 20:34:53
My mk1 golf gti clipper cabrio was WELL SEXY though 8-)
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: nick v6 on 23 February 2009, 20:36:30
Quote
Quote
i'll have a 3 wheeler
elite pete know's how quick there are


Hayabusa Bond Bug or V8 Reliant Rialto?

no just a bog standard plastic pig ;D
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: tyreburner on 23 February 2009, 20:53:17
Quote
Quote
Quote
i'll have a 3 wheeler
elite pete know's how quick there are


Hayabusa Bond Bug or V8 Reliant Rialto?

no just a bog standard plastic pig ;D
The first car i ever drove was an 850cc supersport in blue with a red starsky and hutch style stripe on the side, am suprised it didnt put me off driving for life lol
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Welung666 on 23 February 2009, 20:55:42
First car I ever drove was my moms Triumph 1500TC. First car I owned was a 2.2 auto princess ;D Don't ask ;D
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: TheBoy on 23 February 2009, 21:03:37
thought about it for ages, voted for the GM piece of shite  :-[
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: SP_3.2 on 23 February 2009, 21:04:02
Would have to bee the Saab :y
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Mr Skrunts on 23 February 2009, 21:24:06
As there were only 2 choices I picked Saab to see the results.

But in all honesty I would look completely out of place in a convertable, and I am not a fan of FWD but the Saab looks classier than the Ford and in most cases I reckon Saab had better reliability.
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: jerry on 23 February 2009, 21:44:02
Has to be the saab. Have had escorts of various marks in the past and only recently got to drive a saab because my stepson sells them (along with some v.nice vx cars, including Monaro) and have to say was q.impressed. Just hope that in current climate his job is still secure!
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: VXL V6 on 23 February 2009, 21:49:18
I went for the Saab simply because it's a GM / Cavalier type product with a better public perception to the Ford. (Saab badge IMHO has a better image).

I suppose the other thing to keep in mind is the age of the driver because different age groups will have different views.
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: albitz on 23 February 2009, 21:49:59
A mate of mine bought a Saab turbo convertible recently (03 plate iirc)
been for a drive in it and was completely underwhelmed,no low down power/torque,had to rev the nuts off it to make it go and then it was quite harsh,also not that comfy and the interior has acres of cheap looking plastic.
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: amigov6 on 23 February 2009, 21:56:07
With the possible exception of the Mk1 RS turbo B or C reg (white lightning) all fwd Escorts were wink. Awful handling, gearchanges that were worse than an Austin Maxi & build quality of an Allegro. CVH engine stood for:- Coarse, Vibratory & Harsh
   Best thing about them was they rusted away quickly. ::)
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: cem_devecioglu on 23 February 2009, 21:57:17
deffo Saab even with its high consumption and expensive parts..

escort..no thanks.. (may be will be a good car for wife to practice :D)

Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Darth Loo-knee on 23 February 2009, 22:00:44
Quote
err neither. i would rather walk

That could be arranged ;D
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: philhoward on 23 February 2009, 22:02:13
Glad to know i'm in the majority...

Wife would have chosen the other one though!

If truth be known, i was looking for a 9000 turbo when i found my Mig..and still fancy one.
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Darth Loo-knee on 23 February 2009, 22:04:21
Quote
Quote
Its a no brainer for me, but based on nothing more than the fact every escort I have ever driven, I've crashed.

No desire to look like a woman, I'll have a car with a tin roof.
Though I wouldn't have the saab either, never liked them.

If I HAD to have one I'd be torn  :-/

Probably go for the Ford - better resale value I reckon

Jaime you are the only person on here with any sense other than me I mean :y
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Darth Loo-knee on 23 February 2009, 22:10:47
Quote
thought about it for ages, voted for the GM piece of shite  :-[

Mark has badgered you into it :D
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: amigov6 on 23 February 2009, 22:13:13
Quote
Glad to know i'm in the majority...

Wife would have chosen the other one though!

If truth be known, i was looking for a 9000 turbo when i found my Mig..and still fancy one.
Always liked the 9000 aero, don't really want a convertable though. :y
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: VXL V6 on 23 February 2009, 22:13:40
Quote
Quote
err neither. i would rather walk

That could be arranged ;D

2nd class drive is always better than a first class walk when its raining!  :D
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Jimbo B on 23 February 2009, 22:14:09
definitely the Saab :y :y :y
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Kevin Wood on 23 February 2009, 22:48:49
We need a "none of the above". Both have too many seats to look decent with the top down IMHO.

Kevin
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: sassanach on 23 February 2009, 23:01:24
or more "bodywork" to put the seats into proportion :y
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3538/3305109286_ab8c5b9e67.jpg
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Kevin Wood on 23 February 2009, 23:22:09
Quote
or more "bodywork" to put the seats into proportion :y
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3538/3305109286_ab8c5b9e67.jpg

Yes, that works, actually.

Doesn't look as much fun on the twisties, but I guess you could just chuck a Lotus 7 clone in the boottrunk in case you come across some interesting roads. ;D

Kevin
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: amigov6 on 24 February 2009, 00:03:57
Quote
or more "bodywork" to put the seats into proportion :y
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3538/3305109286_ab8c5b9e67.jpg
That would handle like an elephant on cross ply's but it's cool to cruise. 8-)
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: redelitev6 on 24 February 2009, 19:47:18
Saab will be going strong a long time after the Ford has rusted away!
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: nick v6 on 24 February 2009, 19:59:06
i think everyone loves the escort
just don't want to admit due to the p**s take they will get afterwards
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Mr Skrunts on 24 February 2009, 20:07:34
Quote
i think everyone loves the escort
just don't want to admit due to the p**s take they will get afterwards

Erm, dont think so.  The Mk1 and 2 stood a chance being RWD, but have allways been a VX fan over Ford.


Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: dbug on 24 February 2009, 20:36:44
S A A B  :y
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: waspy on 24 February 2009, 20:37:26
Saab, hands down. I don't like Escorts & never have, only had one & it was crap, oh & an Orion, that was crap too.
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: nick v6 on 24 February 2009, 20:38:04
i wonder who voted for the escort
loo-knee has gotta be one
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Darth Loo-knee on 24 February 2009, 21:13:29
As if I am bothered what everyone thinks anyway ;D

And yes I did vote YES :P
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: nick v6 on 24 February 2009, 21:15:32
Quote
As if I am bothered what everyone thinks anyway ;D

And yes I did vote YES :P

fair play to you
i'm right with you on that one :y
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: AndyVXR300 on 24 February 2009, 21:22:11
Saab i'm afraid, been down the ford route with the RS models over the years and the saab will long outlive the blue oval
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Vamps on 24 February 2009, 21:36:29
Can't help notice how close the result is :)
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Darth Loo-knee on 24 February 2009, 21:37:20
They are all lying  ;D
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: HolyCount on 24 February 2009, 22:26:04
I was so tempted I even started looking them up on Fleabay -- saab that is  ;)
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Big Rod on 24 February 2009, 23:35:58
Saab, all day long!

(But I'd rather have the previous incarnation.)
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: AndyMV6 on 25 February 2009, 20:11:13
Only one convertable id ever consider..................

mk2 Cavalier, oh yea!

Nice caddy sassanach! cant do much more than 9mpg can it?
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: LaserLance on 25 February 2009, 21:12:58
It has to be the SAAB ,but i've only owned 1  softop a truimph spitfire and that put me off for life with convertables .If i want fresh air it has to be a motorbike ;) ;) ;) ;)
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Vamps on 25 February 2009, 21:37:18
Quote
They are all lying  ;D

Was this poll a dig at a recent, perhaps misjudged, decision you made then? I have not read it all :)
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Seth on 25 February 2009, 21:50:38
Gotta be the Swede!

No comparison.
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: HCG on 25 February 2009, 22:37:26
BTW folks, I sat in a Saab 95 a few weeks back - absolute crap leg room! And that was for the driver! Seat would not go back further than, say, an Escort. Unbelievable - walked away.
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: Missy_MV6 on 25 February 2009, 22:48:03
Has to be the Saab ....Looked at a 95 Aero a few years ago but he wanted too much money for it :o

Angie xx
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: LouisCorney on 25 February 2009, 23:32:51
I voted Saab

P.S. Anyone read Evo? There's a 900 convertible currently in their Grand Challenge
Title: Re: Which would you choose
Post by: woodsy_mv6 on 26 February 2009, 10:25:36
Quote
err neither. i would rather walk

Convertibles.........great for showing off your new breasts :y