Omega Owners Forum

Chat Area => General Discussion Area => Topic started by: dbug on 15 September 2010, 19:27:17

Title: Deleted posts
Post by: dbug on 15 September 2010, 19:27:17
Who keeps deleting posts when I am only half way through reading them - its like watching ½ a film  :( :( ;)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Lizzie_Zoom on 15 September 2010, 19:28:49
Yep I know the feeling!! :D :D :D :D ;) ;)

It has happened at least twice recently!! ::) ::) ::) ;)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Tony H on 15 September 2010, 19:31:41
If you are refering to the Ronald Mc Burger one I was just about to contribute to it :-/
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: dbug on 15 September 2010, 19:32:23
Yep two tonight - the last one a few minutes ago - I'd only got one page to go!!  This one will be next  ;D ;D ;)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: TheBoy on 15 September 2010, 19:32:37
I deleted the copper v daft bird lady who may or may not have been phished in the drivers seat one last night.  Much to everyones some people's disgust. Sorry.


The Team have just deleted one of STM0's due to one of the replies being rude, offensive and utterly unacceptable.  And the 'pathetic' was deleted by a Mod, mainly because it had run its course.

HTH
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Andyb on 15 September 2010, 19:32:58
beat ya i got to page 4 lol
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: dbug on 15 September 2010, 19:33:28
Quote
If you are refering to the Ronald Mc Burger one I was just about to contribute to it :-/

Put it on this one mate - I was within 2 pages of the end of that one!! ;D ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: dbug on 15 September 2010, 19:34:19
Quote
I deleted the copper v daft bird lady who may or may not have been phished in the drivers seat one last night.  Much to everyones some people's disgust. Sorry.


The Team have just deleted one of STM0's due to one of the replies being rude, offensive and utterly unacceptable.  And the 'pathetic' was deleted by a Mod, mainly because it had run its course.

HTH

No probs Jaime  :y
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Martin_1962 on 15 September 2010, 19:40:21
Quote
I deleted the copper v daft bird lady who may or may not have been phished in the drivers seat one last night.  Much to everyones some people's disgust. Sorry.


The Team have just deleted one of STM0's due to one of the replies being rude, offensive and utterly unacceptable.  And the 'pathetic' was deleted by a Mod, mainly because it had run its course.

HTH


After I went to all that trouble to find pictures of the admin team!
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: TheBoy on 15 September 2010, 19:43:39
Quote
Quote
I deleted the copper v daft bird lady who may or may not have been phished in the drivers seat one last night.  Much to everyones some people's disgust. Sorry.


The Team have just deleted one of STM0's due to one of the replies being rude, offensive and utterly unacceptable.  And the 'pathetic' was deleted by a Mod, mainly because it had run its course.

HTH


After I went to all that trouble to find pictures of the admin team!
Ah, I missed that bit...


/TB trundles off for a looksie, to see if Imber needs a ban :P
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Martin_1962 on 15 September 2010, 19:46:47
Quote
Quote
Quote
I deleted the copper v daft bird lady who may or may not have been phished in the drivers seat one last night.  Much to everyones some people's disgust. Sorry.


The Team have just deleted one of STM0's due to one of the replies being rude, offensive and utterly unacceptable.  And the 'pathetic' was deleted by a Mod, mainly because it had run its course.

HTH


After I went to all that trouble to find pictures of the admin team!
Ah, I missed that bit...


/TB trundles off for a looksie, to see if Imber needs a ban :P


Brucie liked it!
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: TheBoy on 15 September 2010, 19:49:45
I am not Braveheart though ;)


But Hotel21 is true, that is desperately close to reality, except we wear fedoras and spurs...


Simples...
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Martin_1962 on 15 September 2010, 19:51:58
Quote
I am not Braveheart though ;)


But Hotel21 is true, that is desperately close to reality, except we wear fedoras and spurs...


Simples...


For the people who missed it can you resurrect Debs post and my reply?
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: TheBoy on 15 September 2010, 19:55:32
Quote
Quote
I am not Braveheart though ;)


But Hotel21 is true, that is desperately close to reality, except we wear fedoras and spurs...


Simples...


For the people who missed it can you resurrect Debs post and my reply?
Nope...


...thats a lie, its technically possible, just not worth the effort...


...feel free to repost, if that floats your boat ;)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: TheBoy on 15 September 2010, 19:56:15
And after yesterday, I'm doing no moderation work today ::)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Brikhead on 15 September 2010, 19:58:47
Quote
And after yesterday, I'm doing no moderation work today ::)

So your here because you love the place? 
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Mr Skrunts on 15 September 2010, 20:03:31
Quote
Quote
And after yesterday, I'm doing no moderation work today ::)

So your here because you love the place? 


Of course he is.  ;D ;D :y
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Mysteryman on 15 September 2010, 20:08:37
It's exciting on here. You look at your post count, go to bed and when you walke up it's different. ;D ;D

The phantom night-time thread deleter. OOOER, I scared myself a bit there. :o
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Mr Skrunts on 15 September 2010, 20:10:24
Quote
It's exciting on here. You look at your post count, go to bed and when you walke up it's different. ;D ;D

The phantom night-time thread deleter. OOOER, I scared myself a bit there. :o

You in stirring mode again Steve. ::)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: davethediver on 15 September 2010, 20:11:07
Quote
And after yesterday, I'm doing no moderation work today ::)

Sounds like a guantlet if ever i heard one being thrown down.

Not by me of course ;D ;D :-X
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Mysteryman on 15 September 2010, 20:11:52
Quote
Quote
It's exciting on here. You look at your post count, go to bed and when you walke up it's different. ;D ;D

The phantom night-time thread deleter. OOOER, I scared myself a bit there. :o

You in stirring mode again Steve. ::)


Consistent, that's me :y
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: dbug on 15 September 2010, 20:12:59
Quote
Quote
Quote
It's exciting on here. You look at your post count, go to bed and when you walke up it's different. ;D ;D

The phantom night-time thread deleter. OOOER, I scared myself a bit there. :o

You in stirring mode again Steve. ::)


Consistent, that's me :y

Don't you get my post deleted  >:( :) :) :) ;)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Mysteryman on 15 September 2010, 20:14:17
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
It's exciting on here. You look at your post count, go to bed and when you walke up it's different. ;D ;D

The phantom night-time thread deleter. OOOER, I scared myself a bit there. :o

You in stirring mode again Steve. ::)


Consistent, that's me :y

Don't you get my post deleted  >:( :) :) :) ;)


Of course not :y




Which one? ::)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Mysteryman on 15 September 2010, 20:19:06
Quote
I deleted the copper v daft bird lady who may or may not have been phished in the drivers seat one last night.  Much to everyones some people's disgust. Sorry.


The Team have just deleted one of STM0's due to one of the replies being rude, offensive and utterly unacceptable.  And the 'pathetic' was deleted by a Mod, mainly because it had run its course.

HTH


Not one of my replies BTW. ;)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Mr Skrunts on 15 September 2010, 21:03:13
Quote
Quote
I deleted the copper v daft bird lady who may or may not have been phished in the drivers seat one last night.  Much to everyones some people's disgust. Sorry.


The Team have just deleted one of STM0's due to one of the replies being rude, offensive and utterly unacceptable.  And the 'pathetic' was deleted by a Mod, mainly because it had run its course.

HTH


Not one of my replies BTW. ;)

Maybe not, but a lot of them are.
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Mysteryman on 15 September 2010, 21:03:50
Quote
Quote
Quote
I deleted the copper v daft bird lady who may or may not have been phished in the drivers seat one last night.  Much to everyones some people's disgust. Sorry.


The Team have just deleted one of STM0's due to one of the replies being rude, offensive and utterly unacceptable.  And the 'pathetic' was deleted by a Mod, mainly because it had run its course.

HTH


Not one of my replies BTW. ;)

Maybe not, but a lot of them are.


Who's stirring now, Junior? Sorry, intermediate now. ;D
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Turk on 16 September 2010, 00:56:40
Quote
I deleted the copper v daft bird lady who may or may not have been phished in the drivers seat one last night.  Much to everyones some people's disgust. Sorry.


The Team have just deleted one of STM0's due to one of the replies being rude, offensive and utterly unacceptable.  And the 'pathetic' was deleted by a Mod, mainly because it had run its course.

HTH
Not that I'll lose much sleep over it, but why ?
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: feeutfo on 16 September 2010, 01:06:35
Daw, can't we just lock them? Feel left out now... :'(
 ;D

Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Mr Skrunts on 16 September 2010, 01:14:56
Quote
Daw, can't we just lock them? Feel left out now... :'(
 ;D



lol

I had a couple of days where I was too busy to read the oof, I do a catch up. and there was a 3 page backlog in gen chat, seems RB2 has left, and a few juicy threads have been deleted.  serves me right for taking time out I suppose.  plus to top it all I still aint got my post count back.  ::) :y
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: feeutfo on 16 September 2010, 02:00:34
Quote
Quote
Daw, can't we just lock them? Feel left out now... :'(
 ;D



lol

I had a couple of days where I was too busy to read the oof, I do a catch up. and there was a 3 page backlog in gen chat, seems RB2 has left, and a few juicy threads have been deleted.  serves me right for taking time out I suppose.  plus to top it all I still aint got my post count back.  ::) :y
Skrunitie a naughty boy!

Maybe a hall of shame section, locked of course, no I know it's not going to happen.

Things to do on oof.
King status.
Couple of guides.
Post count cull.
Thread in hall of shame.
Retire happy.  ;D

Or in Estys case
As above...
Strop off and start again. :-X  ;)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Mr Skrunts on 16 September 2010, 02:18:43
Quote
Quote
Quote
Daw, can't we just lock them? Feel left out now... :'(
 ;D



lol

I had a couple of days where I was too busy to read the oof, I do a catch up. and there was a 3 page backlog in gen chat, seems RB2 has left, and a few juicy threads have been deleted.  serves me right for taking time out I suppose.  plus to top it all I still aint got my post count back.  ::) :y
Skrunitie a naughty boy!

Maybe a hall of shame section, locked of course, no I know it's not going to happen.

Things to do on oof.
King status.      been there
Couple of guides.  Would'nt know where to start.
Post count cull.   Current situation
Thread in hall of shame.
Retire happy.  ;D  there's a thought, doubt I would be missed, and plenty would love that, STOM at the top of the list for that one. ;D ;D

Or in Estys case
As above...
Strop off and start again. :-X  ;)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Mysteryman on 16 September 2010, 09:13:42
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Daw, can't we just lock them? Feel left out now... :'(
 ;D



lol

I had a couple of days where I was too busy to read the oof, I do a catch up. and there was a 3 page backlog in gen chat, seems RB2 has left, and a few juicy threads have been deleted.  serves me right for taking time out I suppose.  plus to top it all I still aint got my post count back.  ::) :y
Skrunitie a naughty boy!

Maybe a hall of shame section, locked of course, no I know it's not going to happen.

Things to do on oof.
King status.      been there
Couple of guides.  Would'nt know where to start.
Post count cull.   Current situation
Thread in hall of shame.
Retire happy.  ;D  there's a thought, doubt I would be missed, and plenty would love that, STOM at the top of the list for that one. ;D ;D

Or in Estys case
As above...
Strop off and start again. :-X  ;)

No no no Skruntie. You've got me all wrong.
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Lizzie_Zoom on 16 September 2010, 10:34:15
Once again!!!!!!!!!!

I have just written a post on the religious thread recommending BJ takes it no further.  Go to post it and the thread has GONE, yet again!!

Can we not express our polite opinions anymore? :-/ :-/ :-/

Probably best to delete eventually admins, but can we not discuss it just a bit further as adults? :-/ :-/

 ;) ;)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Debs. on 16 September 2010, 11:26:19
Quote
Probably best to delete eventually admins, but can we not discuss it just a bit further as adults?

Sadly, (based on long experience) it is evident that many such threads will inevitably deteriorate into unpleasantness with vociferous and sometimes personally insulting 'opinions' being expressed under the guise of 'free-speech' or as spreaking as an 'adult'......

The comment by the Cardinal about "agqressive atheism" (strangely) didn`t seem too-far from the truth; for, a mention of having a personal faith/belief these days and one may be the victim of the most insulting diatribe of derision by such "adults". :o

 As with many `another forum, perhaps it`s better to accept that there are still subjects too personal for anonymous and therefore guilt/consequence-free discussions.

I would imagine the OOF admins are heartily sick of such topics and their ultimate consequences! ::)

Surely, nuff-said! ;)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Entwood on 16 September 2010, 11:29:24
Very well said Debs ... 100% agreement with you  :y :y :y
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Lizzie_Zoom on 16 September 2010, 11:33:45
Quote
Quote
Probably best to delete eventually admins, but can we not discuss it just a bit further as adults?

Sadly, (based on long experience) it is evident that many such threads will inevitably deteriorate into unpleasantness with vociferous and sometimes personally insulting 'opinions' being expressed under the guise of 'free-speech' or as spreaking as an 'adult'......

The comment by the Cardinal about "agqressive atheism" (strangely) didn`t seem too-far from the truth; for, a mention of having a personal faith/belief these days and one may be the victim of the most insulting diatribe of derision by such "adults". :o

 As with many `another forum, perhaps it`s better to accept that there are still subjects too personal for anonymous and therefore guilt/consequence-free discussions.

I would imagine the OOF admins are heartily sick of such topics and their ultimate consequences! ::)

Surely, nuff-said! ;)


Yes Debs, you are right of course :y :y :y :y

Shame this is the situation though on the OOF, but we will never change it ::) ::) ::) ;)

I know that I personally are now often not posting on any thread that could be controversial for fear of what will happen! :( :( :(
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: steve_daly on 16 September 2010, 13:55:26
It's a little sad that threads are 'moderated' on what the thread may or may not become before it even has a chance to become anything.

Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Lizzie_Zoom on 16 September 2010, 14:24:06
Quote
It's a little sad that threads are 'moderated' on what the thread may or may not become before it even has a chance to become anything.



That is my point Rufus, but the admins have probably "had enough" (mild language!! ::) ::)) of threads causing them real headaches when being legally responsible the the OOF site. 

Therefore although it is frustrating at times, as I felt this morning after carefully drafting what I thought was a great neutral reply to a potentially damaging thread, we should understand the greater picture that the Admins have to face everyday.  They give their services free, so why should they put up with so much agro from a few difficult members?  I wouldn't!! ::) ::) ::) ;) ;)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: steve_daly on 16 September 2010, 14:37:52
I fully understand your point of view Lizzie. However, punishing the many for the actions of a few isn't really fair.

I have moderated before myself, also for free, and I know it's not an easy job but anticipating what may or may not happen in a thread was certainly a big no no for the company I 'worked' for.

It's a dangerous area because users lose the right (and the will) to freely post their opinions, and a forum ran in that manner soon just becomes a place where anything other than what the mods or owners like is binned.

Of course I don't own or run this place so ultimately if that's how who ever does so chooses to run it, so be it. After all, I or anyone else have the choice not to come here.

It's funny though because in a recent thread someone commented on how new members may be put off joining by some of the content/comments made, I feel though an over moderated stifled forum is far worse than an open one.

We are after all adults does anything written or spoken about on here really offend or upset anyone? It is, after all, not the 'real' world.

Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Lizzie_Zoom on 16 September 2010, 14:39:12
Quote
I fully understand your point of view Lizzie. However, punishing the many for the actions of a few isn't really fair.

I have moderated before myself, also for free, and I know it's not an easy job but anticipating what may or may not happen in a thread was certainly a big no no for the company I 'worked' for.

It's a dangerous area because users lose the right (and the will) to freely post their opinions, and a forum ran in that manner soon just becomes a place where anything other than what the mods or owners like is binned.

Of course I don't own or run this place so ultimately if that's how who ever does so chooses to run it, so be it. After all, I or anyone else have the choice not to come here.

It's funny though because in a recent thread someone commented on how new members may be put off joining by some of the content/comments made, I feel though a over moderated stiffled forum is far worse than an open one.

We are after all adults does anything written or spoken about on here really offend or upset anyone? It is, after all, not the 'real' world.



Fair comment Rufus! 8-) 8-) :y
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: davethediver on 16 September 2010, 15:10:44
Quote
Quote
I fully understand your point of view Lizzie. However, punishing the many for the actions of a few isn't really fair.

I have moderated before myself, also for free, and I know it's not an easy job but anticipating what may or may not happen in a thread was certainly a big no no for the company I 'worked' for.

It's a dangerous area because users lose the right (and the will) to freely post their opinions, and a forum ran in that manner soon just becomes a place where anything other than what the mods or owners like is binned.

Of course I don't own or run this place so ultimately if that's how who ever does so chooses to run it, so be it. After all, I or anyone else have the choice not to come here.

It's funny though because in a recent thread someone commented on how new members may be put off joining by some of the content/comments made, I feel though a over moderated stiffled forum is far worse than an open one.

We are after all adults does anything written or spoken about on here really offend or upset anyone? It is, after all, not the 'real' world.


Fair comment Rufus! 8-) 8-) :y

You mean there's a world outside of OOF tell me more :D :D :D
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: TheBoy on 16 September 2010, 15:50:20
We prefer a 'light touch' moderation scheme, hence have a small mod team. This works best for oof, and has served us well for most of the 4+ yrs.

However, sometimes we have bouts of members being less tolerant, so we have cycles of heavier moderation - and we have to clamp down a bit harder.

EArlier this year we allowed some of these threads to remain longer than we should, and nastiness almost became the norm. We all went through much pain to get the site back on it's rails, and don't want to have to repeat that. I think I've publically said I certainly am not prepared to put that level of work in again, simply because some people are intolerant and think they can hide behind anonymity of the web.


The comment about all being adults is interesting in 2 respects. Some parents, rightly or wrongly, involve their children, and we've always said we are family friendly and open to all.  Also, if we are Adults, how come so many of us sometimes act like children?


I'm all for free speech and freedom, but anybody using that right has to consider the audience, not just themselves. The Internet has bred a generation of people who overly abuse that right.


As a moderator here, i feel whilst we do make mistakes, we (admin team and membership) have got this site going more or less in the right direction, and created a healthy online atmosphere.
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: steve_daly on 16 September 2010, 16:18:03
Don't get me wrong, I'm not for one minute suggesting that a free for all is better, far from it.

Some control obviously needs to be had, the level of swearing kept to a minimum and of course abusive behaviour stomped on all together, so I am fine with how things are done :y

I do love to debate as you may have seen, and rightly or wrongly I like to have my say. But when threads are just removed because they may cause a problem later I don't feel is the right approach. Not everyone will agree or like what someone else says or thinks but that's just a fact of life.

If you would rather certain subjects not touched, then make that clear in a sticky or forum rules. Moving the goal posts because of moderator/owner feelings, workload or previous threads or others past behaviour isn't really fair.

Will another religion thread be removed?

Why did the Koran one stay?

Etc etc.

It's far easier to keep things in check if the users know what can and cannot be touched upon. If one minute something is OK and the next day it isn't it confuses me, let alone that fella that gets confused in M&S ::)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Lizzie_Zoom on 16 September 2010, 16:26:49
Quote
Don't get me wrong, I'm not for one minute suggesting that a free for all is better, far from it.

Some control obviously needs to be had, the level of swearing kept to a minimum and of course abusive behaviour stomped on all together, so I am fine with how things are done :y

I do love to debate as you may have seen, and rightly or wrongly I like to have my say. But when threads are just removed because they may cause a problem later I don't feel is the right approach. Not everyone will agree or like what someone else says or thinks but that's just a fact of life.

If you would rather certain subjects not touched, then make that clear in a sticky or forum rules. Moving the goal posts because of moderator/owner feelings, workload or previous threads or others past behaviour isn't really fair.

Will another religion thread be removed?

Why did the Koran one stay?

Etc etc.

It's far easier to keep things in check if the users know what can and cannot be touched upon. If one minute something is OK and the next day it isn't it confuses me, let alone that fella that gets confused in M&S ::)


Once again Rufus, very fair and true comment :y :y

There does seem to be different rules for one thread and another on the same subject ::) ::) ::)

Threads on religion and politics often attract intense debate, that can go pear shaped don't I know!! ::) ::)   But to ban them before they get going??  Not sure about that really.
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Dishevelled Den on 16 September 2010, 16:51:52
The following is contained in the Forum Guidelines.


The decision of the Admin Team is final, and a long drawn out post mortem on any action or decision is never helpful.


Which says it all really. :y

Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Mr Skrunts on 16 September 2010, 16:54:00
Some interesting points there Rufus.  But I am with the Admin team here.  I have seen a lot of threads start , develope and completely errumpt, simply because of one or 2 members (and with respect to all involved - they are generally the newer members) trying to get thier points accross in any way they can with out being open minded or agree to disagree.

If you follow most threads carefully you will see there is a balance and self moderate, and if the debate is reasonable the Admin just monitor it but are ready to pounce, delete or even NUKE the thread if they see fit.  I have even knon TheBoy to pull a thread, let everyone
.0 chill and then enable it, which in all honesty could well work in the future.

The 2 types of thread that allways seem to be the problem causers are the religeous and the racial ones.  A lot of us have a varied sence of humour and see past the problem and see it in the light hearted way it was meant. But if it hits a nerve for any reason with a single member then it becomes out of order and therefore best avoided, time and experiance on the forum help understand that.  But adding to that in some cases it's open to discussion.

Admin have a crucial job of striking a balance that could sway either way, plus, and one that a lot forget, keeping the site LEGAL.  We have known situations here where it has got out of hand it was so bad the site nearly got  the plug pulled because of all the agro that was happening in the threads.

So the point I started with of backing the Admin/Mod team is that what they have learnt over the last 4+ years does work and the reason that the OOF community grows on a weekly basis, no every thing will not please eveyone, but that's life, and judgeing by the ammount of people here every week they agree.  :y
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Lizzie_Zoom on 16 September 2010, 17:09:27
Quote
Some interesting points there Rufus.  But I am with the Admin team here.  I have seen a lot of threads start , develope and completely errumpt, simply because of one or 2 members (and with respect to all involved - they are generally the newer members) trying to get thier points accross in any way they can with out being open minded or agree to disagree.

If you follow most threads carefully you will see there is a balance and self moderate, and if the debate is reasonable the Admin just monitor it but are ready to pounce, delete or even NUKE the thread if they see fit.  I have even knon TheBoy to pull a thread, let everyone
.0 chill and then enable it, which in all honesty could well work in the future.

The 2 types of thread that allways seem to be the problem causers are the religeous and the racial ones.  A lot of us have a varied sence of humour and see past the problem and see it in the light hearted way it was meant. But if it hits a nerve for any reason with a single member then it becomes out of order and therefore best avoided, time and experiance on the forum help understand that.  But adding to that in some cases it's open to discussion.

Admin have a crucial job of striking a balance that could sway either way, plus, and one that a lot forget, keeping the site LEGAL.  We have known situations here where it has got out of hand it was so bad the site nearly got  the plug pulled because of all the agro that was happening in the threads.

So the point I started with of backing the Admin/Mod team is that what they have learnt over the last 4+ years does work and the reason that the OOF community grows on a weekly basis, no every thing will not please eveyone, but that's life, and judgeing by the ammount of people here every week they agree.  :y


You make a lot of the points I made earlier to Rufus Zulu Skruntie.  However you, nor did I, really answer his main question ::) ::) ::)

Why was the thread on Religion so quickly 'pulled' after just the initial posting and your answer (which would have been followed by mine) when the one on "International Burn-a-Koran Day!" was not and ran for pages.  If you look at the opening gambit of the latter it was already full of contention, being certainly judged by me, Proz, and obviously The Boy who posted a warning, as being a very dangerous area for OOF debate, so why was that not pulled as well?

That is what Rufus is fairly asking, which I think is a fair point.

The Admins of course have the final say, but should we not have a set Standard; no religious threads?? :-/ :-/
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Mysteryman on 16 September 2010, 17:17:34
Quote
Some interesting points there Rufus.  But I am with the Admin team here.  I have seen a lot of threads start , develope and completely errumpt, simply because of one or 2 members (and with respect to all involved - they are generally the newer members) trying to get thier points accross in any way they can with out being open minded or agree to disagree.

If you follow most threads carefully you will see there is a balance and self moderate, and if the debate is reasonable the Admin just monitor it but are ready to pounce, delete or even NUKE the thread if they see fit.  I have even knon TheBoy to pull a thread, let everyone
.0 chill and then enable it, which in all honesty could well work in the future.

The 2 types of thread that allways seem to be the problem causers are the religeous and the racial ones.  A lot of us have a varied sence of humour and see past the problem and see it in the light hearted way it was meant. But if it hits a nerve for any reason with a single member then it becomes out of order and therefore best avoided, time and experiance on the forum help understand that.  But adding to that in some cases it's open to discussion.

Admin have a crucial job of striking a balance that could sway either way, plus, and one that a lot forget, keeping the site LEGAL.  We have known situations here where it has got out of hand it was so bad the site nearly got  the plug pulled because of all the agro that was happening in the threads.

So the point I started with of backing the Admin/Mod team is that what they have learnt over the last 4+ years does work and the reason that the OOF community grows on a weekly basis, no every thing will not please eveyone, but that's life, and judgeing by the ammount of people here every week they agree.  :y


In your rather dreams ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: hotel21 on 16 September 2010, 17:54:56
The point that should perhaps be bourne in mind here is that there are more than one mod/admin. 

Each may or may not read EVERYTHING posted on here and may choose to rely on the admin team sharing the load/responsibility.

Ultimately, thread content is read by one or more of the admin team in the same way that users do and, in common with all OOF users, each can make a descision on the post/thread as to whether it needs moderation or not.  Whats perceived as acceptable by one of the team may be wholly unacceptable to someone else, hence one may allow a posting to stay whilst another will delete or moderate it.  That said, extremes of toleration are few and far between.

Hopefully the admin team have a reasonably level standard of the acceptable and, as TB says, none of us want to have to re-tread the path that was on here some weeks ago when OOF was not a pretty place to be and the workload on the admin team to try and get it back onto track was horrendous.
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Lizzie_Zoom on 16 September 2010, 18:00:05
Quote
The point that should perhaps be bourne in mind here is that there are more than one mod/admin. 

Each may or may not read EVERYTHING posted on here and may choose to rely on the admin team sharing the load/responsibility.

Ultimately, thread content is read by one or more of the admin team in the same way that users do and, in common with all OOF users, each can make a descision on the post/thread as to whether it needs moderation or not.  Whats perceived as acceptable by one of the team may be wholly unacceptable to someone else, hence one may allow a posting to stay whilst another will delete or moderate it.  That said, extremes of toleration are few and far between.

Hopefully the admin team have a reasonably level standard of the acceptable and, as TB says, none of us want to have to re-tread the path that was on here some weeks ago when OOF was not a pretty place to be and the workload on the admin team to try and get it back onto track was horrendous.


Ah, that is logical H, and very understandable 8-) 8-). Thanks :y :y
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: steve_daly on 16 September 2010, 20:05:54
Quote
The point that should perhaps be bourne in mind here is that there are more than one mod/admin. 

Each may or may not read EVERYTHING posted on here and may choose to rely on the admin team sharing the load/responsibility.

Ultimately, thread content is read by one or more of the admin team in the same way that users do and, in common with all OOF users, each can make a descision on the post/thread as to whether it needs moderation or not.  Whats perceived as acceptable by one of the team may be wholly unacceptable to someone else, hence one may allow a posting to stay whilst another will delete or moderate it.  That said, extremes of toleration are few and far between.

Hopefully the admin team have a reasonably level standard of the acceptable and, as TB says, none of us want to have to re-tread the path that was on here some weeks ago when OOF was not a pretty place to be and the workload on the admin team to try and get it back onto track was horrendous.

The forum I helped to maintain had maybe easy 20+ moderators at any one time, ages ranging from mid teens to 40 somethings like me and with a mix of nationalities so I fully understand the difficulties involved and the differences in what one feels acceptable and what another doesn't.

Still, it's you guys that run the place so obviously you do so as you see fit but deleting entire threads is a little draconian especially as it may not have become the monster you feared it would. You should either let people make up their own minds or set a standard so we all know what we can and cannot post about. Now no-one knows because the thread vanished.

Religion is always a touchy subject, that's what makes debating it so interesting, when allowed. And from what I saw of the thread before it vanished, nothing appeared unacceptable :-?

As difficult as it is it would be better from a users point of view to know what is and isn't acceptable as a rule instead of just what is and isn't depending on who is moderating. That is easier done in a thread that can be seen and perhaps deleting individual posts rather than entire threads.
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: TheBoy on 16 September 2010, 20:41:13
I'll try to clarify a couple of points that have been raised with regard to (perceived?) inconsistencies.

This is my view on moderation (OOF specifically - each other forum I moderate has a different set of needs).  It may or may not match that of other members of the Admin Team.


You will note, we don't have rules, we have guidelines. This should be clear enough to know the kind of behaviour expected of members (and mods  :-[), rather than an unmanagable 'rulebook'.  It also allows us (mods) some degree of flexibility.

Generally, we try to allow as much 'freedom' as possible, within the confines of the rules.  Sometimes, as I previously hinted at a few posts ago, we have a heightened sense of (lets call it nastiness/intolerance).  We have to take the current level of nastiness into account.

When the nastiness level is low, we can allow a little more freedom.  If the level rises, because generally people are at each others throats, we have to be a bit more strict.


The Burn a Religious Book thread happened in a time when things we good.  It was still a borderline subject (based on previous experience, and our global audience), hence the warning in that thread.  A couple of days ago, there was a fairly high profile spat on the site, and the usual long, drawn out postmortem - which is never constructive in these cases - unsurprisingly caused the 'nastiness level' to start to creep up.  Thus controversial threads in the last couple of days have had less slack.

Also, as Hotel21 suggested, although all the members of the Admin Team have similar views on what is acceptable here, we are all individuals.  If its a borderline subject, Hotel21, for example, may think its just on the acceptable side of the line, and I may think its just on the unacceptable side.  Each of us may also be taking into account other factors that the other may not be entirely familiar with.



As to whole threads getting nuked, we have a limited Admin Team, and remember we can see a little more than non privileged users with regard to what users are doing, sometimes it is easier to simply remove the entire thread than it is to chase the constant posts on it.  Its not unheard of for an entire section to get shut down to give our Mods some breathing space to tidy the section up. Rare, but happenes.

Also, be aware, many of the Mods are very busy people, and squeeze in what mod time they can, which often means trying to do it on mobile phones. Editing posts on phones isn't easy, and can be time consuming. Removing threads is quick and easy.  This sentence is my own view, and likely doesn't match what most of the other members of the Admin Team think  ::)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Entwood on 16 September 2010, 21:43:31
Well said TB .. upfront and honest as usual  :y :y :y

Donning the "tin hat" for a second ... OOF started off as a car help forum with a small "general chat" ... it now seems to be more of a "chat room" to some members than a car forum ...

Perhaps this is why the antagonism arises ???... some of the "Spirit of OOF" has been lost somewhere ???
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: hotel21 on 16 September 2010, 21:51:19
Quote
Also, as Hotel21 suggested, although all the members of the Admin Team have similar views on what is acceptable here, we are all individuals.  If its a borderline subject, Hotel21, for example, may think its just on the acceptable side of the line, and I may think its just on the unacceptable side.  Each of us may also be taking into account other factors that the other may not be entirely familiar with.

Further to the above, I would suggest that by such an approach, OOF evolves into a better place overall as its the tighter standard from all mods thats then being applied, rather than the looser one, if you follow?

I accept that culling a post or the whole thread may seem draconian but, as TB says, myself and others peruse the forum frequently during the day from mobiles and splitting/splicing posts or moving them etc is a right royal pain in the harris.  Its a cop out, I know, but straightforward to 'hide' a thread pending edit or reinstatement later once home....
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Richie London on 16 September 2010, 22:13:42
i cant be dealing with threads where members dont agree with other peoples opinions and get nasty,even though i can be an asshole sometimes myself, have enough of it outside in the real world. i come on here for advice and have a laugh to unwind from the stress from the daytime, i hate to fall out with people, especially on such a great site as this. and theres not 1 person i can say i dislike on here at all. i wont even bother reading them if i think its going into a row. i abide by the rules and accept them as i did when i first joined this site  :y
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: feeutfo on 17 September 2010, 00:18:31
Seems to me the post-mortems take more admin time than the original conflict of opinion, it's done, legs slapped, move on. IMO.
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Mr Skrunts on 17 September 2010, 00:21:06
Quote
Quote
Some interesting points there Rufus.  But I am with the Admin team here.  I have seen a lot of threads start , develope and completely errumpt, simply because of one or 2 members (and with respect to all involved - they are generally the newer members) trying to get thier points accross in any way they can with out being open minded or agree to disagree.

If you follow most threads carefully you will see there is a balance and self moderate, and if the debate is reasonable the Admin just monitor it but are ready to pounce, delete or even NUKE the thread if they see fit.  I have even knon TheBoy to pull a thread, let everyone
.0 chill and then enable it, which in all honesty could well work in the future.

The 2 types of thread that allways seem to be the problem causers are the religeous and the racial ones.  A lot of us have a varied sence of humour and see past the problem and see it in the light hearted way it was meant. But if it hits a nerve for any reason with a single member then it becomes out of order and therefore best avoided, time and experiance on the forum help understand that.  But adding to that in some cases it's open to discussion.

Admin have a crucial job of striking a balance that could sway either way, plus, and one that a lot forget, keeping the site LEGAL.  We have known situations here where it has got out of hand it was so bad the site nearly got  the plug pulled because of all the agro that was happening in the threads.

So the point I started with of backing the Admin/Mod team is that what they have learnt over the last 4+ years does work and the reason that the OOF community grows on a weekly basis, no every thing will not please eveyone, but that's life, and judgeing by the ammount of people here every week they agree.  :y


You make a lot of the points I made earlier to Rufus Zulu Skruntie.  However you, nor did I, really answer his main question ::) ::) ::)

Why was the thread on Religion so quickly 'pulled' after just the initial posting and your answer (which would have been followed by mine) when the one on "International Burn-a-Koran Day!" was not and ran for pages.  If you look at the opening gambit of the latter it was already full of contention, being certainly judged by me, Proz, and obviously The Boy who posted a warning, as being a very dangerous area for OOF debate, so why was that not pulled as well?

That is what Rufus is fairly asking, which I think is a fair point.

The Admins of course have the final say, but should we not have a set Standard; no religious threads?? :-/ :-/

Simple in my case Lizzie, I cant comment on what I did.nr read, and neither have I read the koran thread, allthough I do have my views and reason's but I certainly would'nt debate religious matters on here.

As above I wont debate religeous, plus polital or racial matters and posibly a few others.

Why? - read the bottom of every post I make.

Ask yourself :  " WHY do I believe what I believe?"

Remember that my opinions expressed here are not representative of the opinions of other members on the OOF Forum.
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Lizzie_Zoom on 17 September 2010, 17:04:30
Quote
Quote
Quote
Some interesting points there Rufus.  But I am with the Admin team here.  I have seen a lot of threads start , develope and completely errumpt, simply because of one or 2 members (and with respect to all involved - they are generally the newer members) trying to get thier points accross in any way they can with out being open minded or agree to disagree.

If you follow most threads carefully you will see there is a balance and self moderate, and if the debate is reasonable the Admin just monitor it but are ready to pounce, delete or even NUKE the thread if they see fit.  I have even knon TheBoy to pull a thread, let everyone
.0 chill and then enable it, which in all honesty could well work in the future.

The 2 types of thread that allways seem to be the problem causers are the religeous and the racial ones.  A lot of us have a varied sence of humour and see past the problem and see it in the light hearted way it was meant. But if it hits a nerve for any reason with a single member then it becomes out of order and therefore best avoided, time and experiance on the forum help understand that.  But adding to that in some cases it's open to discussion.

Admin have a crucial job of striking a balance that could sway either way, plus, and one that a lot forget, keeping the site LEGAL.  We have known situations here where it has got out of hand it was so bad the site nearly got  the plug pulled because of all the agro that was happening in the threads.

So the point I started with of backing the Admin/Mod team is that what they have learnt over the last 4+ years does work and the reason that the OOF community grows on a weekly basis, no every thing will not please eveyone, but that's life, and judgeing by the ammount of people here every week they agree.  :y


You make a lot of the points I made earlier to Rufus Zulu Skruntie.  However you, nor did I, really answer his main question ::) ::) ::)

Why was the thread on Religion so quickly 'pulled' after just the initial posting and your answer (which would have been followed by mine) when the one on "International Burn-a-Koran Day!" was not and ran for pages.  If you look at the opening gambit of the latter it was already full of contention, being certainly judged by me, Proz, and obviously The Boy who posted a warning, as being a very dangerous area for OOF debate, so why was that not pulled as well?

That is what Rufus is fairly asking, which I think is a fair point.

The Admins of course have the final say, but should we not have a set Standard; no religious threads?? :-/ :-/

Simple in my case Lizzie, I cant comment on what I did.nr read, and neither have I read the koran thread, allthough I do have my views and reason's but I certainly would'nt debate religious matters on here.

As above I wont debate religeous, plus polital or racial matters and posibly a few others.

Why? - read the bottom of every post I make.

Ask yourself :  " WHY do I believe what I believe?"

Remember that my opinions expressed here are not representative of the opinions of other members on the OOF Forum.


That's right Skruntie, and you are wise not to.  My question was though (now clearly well answered by Ht21 and TB) why was one thread pulled when the other one was allowed to continue.

Going on from what you correctly state Skruntie, should the forum have a policy of no discussion on Religion or Race to avoid the heartache and work they give the Admins?  Do all members need the heartache also that can lead to high blood pressue?

After all the OOF IS a car forum, no more, no less! ::) ::)

 ;) ;)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Darth Loo-knee on 17 September 2010, 18:04:50
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Some interesting points there Rufus.  But I am with the Admin team here.  I have seen a lot of threads start , develope and completely errumpt, simply because of one or 2 members (and with respect to all involved - they are generally the newer members) trying to get thier points accross in any way they can with out being open minded or agree to disagree.

If you follow most threads carefully you will see there is a balance and self moderate, and if the debate is reasonable the Admin just monitor it but are ready to pounce, delete or even NUKE the thread if they see fit.  I have even knon TheBoy to pull a thread, let everyone
.0 chill and then enable it, which in all honesty could well work in the future.

The 2 types of thread that allways seem to be the problem causers are the religeous and the racial ones.  A lot of us have a varied sence of humour and see past the problem and see it in the light hearted way it was meant. But if it hits a nerve for any reason with a single member then it becomes out of order and therefore best avoided, time and experiance on the forum help understand that.  But adding to that in some cases it's open to discussion.

Admin have a crucial job of striking a balance that could sway either way, plus, and one that a lot forget, keeping the site LEGAL.  We have known situations here where it has got out of hand it was so bad the site nearly got  the plug pulled because of all the agro that was happening in the threads.

So the point I started with of backing the Admin/Mod team is that what they have learnt over the last 4+ years does work and the reason that the OOF community grows on a weekly basis, no every thing will not please eveyone, but that's life, and judgeing by the ammount of people here every week they agree.  :y


You make a lot of the points I made earlier to Rufus Zulu Skruntie.  However you, nor did I, really answer his main question ::) ::) ::)

Why was the thread on Religion so quickly 'pulled' after just the initial posting and your answer (which would have been followed by mine) when the one on "International Burn-a-Koran Day!" was not and ran for pages.  If you look at the opening gambit of the latter it was already full of contention, being certainly judged by me, Proz, and obviously The Boy who posted a warning, as being a very dangerous area for OOF debate, so why was that not pulled as well?

That is what Rufus is fairly asking, which I think is a fair point.

The Admins of course have the final say, but should we not have a set Standard; no religious threads?? :-/ :-/

Simple in my case Lizzie, I cant comment on what I did.nr read, and neither have I read the koran thread, allthough I do have my views and reason's but I certainly would'nt debate religious matters on here.

As above I wont debate religeous, plus polital or racial matters and posibly a few others.

Why? - read the bottom of every post I make.

Ask yourself :  " WHY do I believe what I believe?"

Remember that my opinions expressed here are not representative of the opinions of other members on the OOF Forum.


That's right Skruntie, and you are wise not to.  My question was though (now clearly well answered by Ht21 and TB) why was one thread pulled when the other one was allowed to continue.

Going on from what you correctly state Skruntie, should the forum have a policy of no discussion on Religion or Race to avoid the heartache and work they give the Admins?  Do all members need the heartache also that can lead to high blood pressue?

After all the OOF IS a car forum, no more, no less! ::) ::)

 ;) ;)


As long as I have been on The Forum its always being a "Think about what your putting place."
I swear as much if not more than most, anyone that has met me will know that.. I do not do it on here though. I love Women and the tongue in cheek banter with them but would not insult them.

I have deleted whole threads Lizzie, as I have had several complaints about them. Being fair I don't have the time to read through the insults be it sexist, racist etc... But should we need to do that??? People keep saying we are adults on here so why is there a need to keep deleting posts/threads?? The idea of the Guidelines not Rules has created a more relaxed place to be most of the time.

Anyway this has all been said before, and for any of us to keep going on and on about the same thing is tedious.

 :)
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: Mysteryman on 17 September 2010, 18:50:25
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Some interesting points there Rufus.  But I am with the Admin team here.  I have seen a lot of threads start , develope and completely errumpt, simply because of one or 2 members (and with respect to all involved - they are generally the newer members) trying to get thier points accross in any way they can with out being open minded or agree to disagree.

If you follow most threads carefully you will see there is a balance and self moderate, and if the debate is reasonable the Admin just monitor it but are ready to pounce, delete or even NUKE the thread if they see fit.  I have even knon TheBoy to pull a thread, let everyone
.0 chill and then enable it, which in all honesty could well work in the future.

The 2 types of thread that allways seem to be the problem causers are the religeous and the racial ones.  A lot of us have a varied sence of humour and see past the problem and see it in the light hearted way it was meant. But if it hits a nerve for any reason with a single member then it becomes out of order and therefore best avoided, time and experiance on the forum help understand that.  But adding to that in some cases it's open to discussion.

Admin have a crucial job of striking a balance that could sway either way, plus, and one that a lot forget, keeping the site LEGAL.  We have known situations here where it has got out of hand it was so bad the site nearly got  the plug pulled because of all the agro that was happening in the threads.

So the point I started with of backing the Admin/Mod team is that what they have learnt over the last 4+ years does work and the reason that the OOF community grows on a weekly basis, no every thing will not please eveyone, but that's life, and judgeing by the ammount of people here every week they agree.  :y


You make a lot of the points I made earlier to Rufus Zulu Skruntie.  However you, nor did I, really answer his main question ::) ::) ::)

Why was the thread on Religion so quickly 'pulled' after just the initial posting and your answer (which would have been followed by mine) when the one on "International Burn-a-Koran Day!" was not and ran for pages.  If you look at the opening gambit of the latter it was already full of contention, being certainly judged by me, Proz, and obviously The Boy who posted a warning, as being a very dangerous area for OOF debate, so why was that not pulled as well?

That is what Rufus is fairly asking, which I think is a fair point.

The Admins of course have the final say, but should we not have a set Standard; no religious threads?? :-/ :-/

Simple in my case Lizzie, I cant comment on what I did.nr read, and neither have I read the koran thread, allthough I do have my views and reason's but I certainly would'nt debate religious matters on here.

As above I wont debate religeous, plus polital or racial matters and posibly a few others.

Why? - read the bottom of every post I make.

Ask yourself :  " WHY do I believe what I believe?"

Remember that my opinions expressed here are not representative of the opinions of other members on the OOF Forum.


That's right Skruntie, and you are wise not to.  My question was though (now clearly well answered by Ht21 and TB) why was one thread pulled when the other one was allowed to continue.

Going on from what you correctly state Skruntie, should the forum have a policy of no discussion on Religion or Race to avoid the heartache and work they give the Admins?  Do all members need the heartache also that can lead to high blood pressue?

After all the OOF IS a car forum, no more, no less! ::) ::)

 ;) ;)


As long as I have been on The Forum its always being a "Think about what your putting place."
I swear as much if not more than most, anyone that has met me will know that.. I do not do it on here though. I love Women and the tongue in cheek banter with them but would not insult them.

I have deleted whole threads Lizzie, as I have had several complaints about them. Being fair I don't have the time to read through the insults be it sexist, racist etc... But should we need to do that??? People keep saying we are adults on here so why is there a need to keep deleting posts/threads?? The idea of the Guidelines not Rules has created a more relaxed place to be most of the time.

Anyway this has all been said before, and for any of us to keep going on and on about the same thing is tedious.

 :)
 


Well shut up then, peabrain. ;D
Title: Re: Deleted posts
Post by: TheBoy on 17 September 2010, 18:55:51
I think there is nothing more to add to this thread, I believe all questions have been answered, if any aren't, PM me.

Thankyou for your input.