Omega Owners Forum

Chat Area => General Car Chat => Topic started by: MickAP on 06 July 2010, 19:02:31

Title: New car???
Post by: MickAP on 06 July 2010, 19:02:31
Well new to me, but secondhand.

After much searching and fact finding, mainly on  tinternet, I've come to the conclusion that there ain't much out there to replace my TD estate with.
It's getting on a bit, it's slow to take off but once it's got going, it's a good load lugger and good cruiser.
And at 33mpg local running, and around 44 on a run not bad economy.

I was thinking of another diesel estate of some sort BMW 5 series, X-type Jag, Volvo V50, Vectra CDTi, VW Passat, Audi A4, Mondeo ......err not really :-/ are contenders but seem to have their faults one way or another. Some even out of my price range.
Up to £6,000 maybe to spend..................
so what's out there that fits the bill, if anything?

I can't make my mind up, what to do :-/

Mick :-/
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: joshwyatt on 06 July 2010, 19:10:21
I'd have either a Volvo V70 or BMW 5 series.
A '54' plate V70 or later, as tha when the facelift came in, 'SE' spec with the D5 engine. It's a straight 5cyl turbo diesel engine, it produces 185bhp, sounds lovely and rturns very good MPG. It is FWD, bt not a bad car to drive at all, I enjoy driving them.
Failing that I would go for a 5 series, 525d or 530d.
I wouldn't go for a Merc, I sold an '04' E220 CDI estate with 103,000 miles for £7900. Classic spec, so base model, but still got sec levels. But I wouldn't want another.
Vectra isn't bad, the 3.0 V6 CDTI is good, but don't get an auto one, it'll destrory the gearbox...you must have a manual or you'll be having problems.

I'd recommend either a V70 or 5 series.
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: tunnie on 06 July 2010, 19:11:55
not  a diesel, but these are growing on me:

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201023361000208/sort/priceasc/usedcars/body-type/estate/price-from/5000/model/legacy/make/subaru/radius/1501/postcode/rg64da/page/1/keywords/spec%20b?logcode=p
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: Dishevelled Den on 06 July 2010, 19:16:09
Quote
not  a diesel, but these are growing on me:

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201023361000208/sort/priceasc/usedcars/body-type/estate/price-from/5000/model/legacy/make/subaru/radius/1501/postcode/rg64da/page/1/keywords/spec%20b?logcode=p


Agreed - very capable cars indeed, althougth a bit on the thirsty side. :-* :y :y
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: henryd on 06 July 2010, 19:31:12
hows about a chrysler 300c with a merc diesel lump in it,I do like the look of them but being a yank not sure how good the rest is
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: tunnie on 06 July 2010, 19:33:53
Quote
hows about a chrysler 300c with a merc diesel lump in it,I do like the look of them but being a yank not sure how good the rest is

Its not, autoboxes die less than 20k old, terrible, terrible build all over. Merc is not exactly well built these days, this is the budget version
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: henryd on 06 July 2010, 19:42:39
Quote
Quote
hows about a chrysler 300c with a merc diesel lump in it,I do like the look of them but being a yank not sure how good the rest is

Its not, autoboxes die less than 20k old, terrible, terrible build all over. Merc is not exactly well built these days, this is the budget version

shame cause I think there a real looker
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: MickAP on 06 July 2010, 19:51:54
Quote
Quote
Quote
hows about a chrysler 300c with a merc diesel lump in it,I do like the look of them but being a yank not sure how good the rest is

Its not, autoboxes die less than 20k old, terrible, terrible build all over. Merc is not exactly well built these days, this is the budget version

shame cause I think there a real looker

Yes I've also taken a look at them, not in the flesh. Out of my price range though, so not a contender.

Mick :y
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: MickAP on 06 July 2010, 19:55:43
Quote
Quote
not  a diesel, but these are growing on me:

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201023361000208/sort/priceasc/usedcars/body-type/estate/price-from/5000/model/legacy/make/subaru/radius/1501/postcode/rg64da/page/1/keywords/spec%20b?logcode=p


Agreed - very capable cars indeed, althougth a bit on the thirsty side. :-* :y :y

Agreed :(, I do like it though.

Mick ;)
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: kineavy on 06 July 2010, 20:02:58
I would go for a Mondeo ST TDCi and get it remapped.
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: Dishevelled Den on 06 July 2010, 20:07:17
Quote
Quote
Quote
not  a diesel, but these are growing on me:

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/201023361000208/sort/priceasc/usedcars/body-type/estate/price-from/5000/model/legacy/make/subaru/radius/1501/postcode/rg64da/page/1/keywords/spec%20b?logcode=p


Agreed - very capable cars indeed, althougth a bit on the thirsty side. :-* :y :y

Agreed :(, I do like it though.

Mick ;)

Banjax runs a Legacy Sport Mick, might be worthwhile giving him a pm to get his take :y
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: Del Boy on 06 July 2010, 21:31:07
I'm with Josh on this, V70 or a 5 Series  :y
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: MickAP on 07 July 2010, 00:42:50
Quote
I'd have either a Volvo V70 or BMW 5 series.
A '54' plate V70 or later, as tha when the facelift came in, 'SE' spec with the D5 engine. It's a straight 5cyl turbo diesel engine, it produces 185bhp, sounds lovely and rturns very good MPG. It is FWD, bt not a bad car to drive at all, I enjoy driving them.
Failing that I would go for a 5 series, 525d or 530d.
I wouldn't go for a Merc, I sold an '04' E220 CDI estate with 103,000 miles for £7900. Classic spec, so base model, but still got sec levels. But I wouldn't want another.
Vectra isn't bad, the 3.0 V6 CDTI is good, but don't get an auto one, it'll destrory the gearbox...you must have a manual or you'll be having problems.

I'd recommend either a V70 or 5 series.

Auto or manuals best for both?

And why post 54 plate on the Volvo V70 diesel?

Mick ;)
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: Broomies Mate on 07 July 2010, 00:48:33
Quote
Quote
I'd have either a Volvo V70 or BMW 5 series.
A '54' plate V70 or later, as tha when the facelift came in, 'SE' spec with the D5 engine. It's a straight 5cyl turbo diesel engine, it produces 185bhp, sounds lovely and rturns very good MPG. It is FWD, bt not a bad car to drive at all, I enjoy driving them.
Failing that I would go for a 5 series, 525d or 530d.
I wouldn't go for a Merc, I sold an '04' E220 CDI estate with 103,000 miles for £7900. Classic spec, so base model, but still got sec levels. But I wouldn't want another.
Vectra isn't bad, the 3.0 V6 CDTI is good, but don't get an auto one, it'll destrory the gearbox...you must have a manual or you'll be having problems.

I'd recommend either a V70 or 5 series.

Auto or manuals best for both?

And why post 54 plate on the Volvo V70 diesel?

Mick ;)

As in his post, thats when the Facelift came in!  :y
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: Squealey on 07 July 2010, 05:14:09
Does it have to be an estate, what about a bloody big hatchback. A fully loaded Signum 3.0 V6 TDi
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: hoody on 07 July 2010, 09:21:07
Honda Accord,lovely cars in executive spec.
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: MickAP on 07 July 2010, 10:06:41
Quote
Does it have to be an estate, what about a bloody big hatchback. A fully loaded Signum 3.0 V6 TDi

I like those too, and they are cheapish to buy.
They never really took off and sold in great numbers, diesel look good economy.

I'm half thinking saloon, but might regret later when I need a load lugger to shift stuff.
If a saloon then the Skoda Superb (diesel) looks a very good buy, seems a reliable motor and well liked.
Seen an 04 plate Comfort spec with 87k on for £4250, seems a good buy.

Mick ;)
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: Dishevelled Den on 07 July 2010, 10:52:17
Quote
Quote
Does it have to be an estate, what about a bloody big hatchback. A fully loaded Signum 3.0 V6 TDi

I like those too, and they are cheapish to buy.
They never really took off and sold in great numbers, diesel look good economy.

I'm half thinking saloon, but might regret later when I need a load lugger to shift stuff.
If a saloon then the Skoda Superb (diesel) looks a very good buy, seems a reliable motor and well liked.
Seen an 04 plate Comfort spec with 87k on for £4250, seems a good buy.

Mick ;)


Having made the move from a Volvo XC70 T5 (because I didn't like the 5 speed manual box) to the Omega saloon (couldn't get the estate at the time) I would say that you'll regret not holding out for an estate.
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: MickAP on 08 July 2010, 17:41:20
As the song goes (U2)

"Still haven't found what I'm looking for"

So I give up till after my hols :y

Mick ;)
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: Seth on 10 July 2010, 00:37:01
If I was going to replace my TD Estate, I'd be seriously looking at a Volvo V70 Estate Mick - absolute 'boss' mate!
 :y
Although they're FWD; I've not heard any adverse comments about them regarding their towing capabilities.
 ;)
Title: Re: New car???
Post by: omegadan67 on 10 July 2010, 23:40:59
volvo's dont they have rear wheel bearing problems?
Anyway i would go for a bmw 530d se spec or a merc e320 advantgarde spec