Omega Owners Forum

Chat Area => General Discussion Area => Topic started by: raximax on 03 January 2008, 23:19:50

Title: senator vs omega
Post by: raximax on 03 January 2008, 23:19:50
let me no your thoughts on the matter....
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: Admin on 03 January 2008, 23:42:23
I have owned quite a few of each.

The Omega is a more advanced and better handling car.... but I will take the Senator every single time. :)

It is one of those "special" cars, those that have an unquantifiable something. It really does stir my soul.

Oh and I think the Senator is more reliable ;)
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: Andy B on 04 January 2008, 04:54:52
I wonder if you can guess which way I voted.  ::)
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: tunnie on 04 January 2008, 09:19:36
i have 2 Omega facelifts, but i still have a soft spot for the old Senator...

I did over 2,000 miles in 2 weeks in Senny in Europe this year, never missed a beat.

Cracking cars... the omega is far more refined at speed.
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: Kevin Wood on 04 January 2008, 09:20:04
Umm. A tough one. I'm with Laidback. V6 Omega is the better car in most respects, though plagued with niggles at times, but the Senator has "something" that's missing on the Omega.

I think it's down to the little bit of demarkation between the Carlton and Senator which marked the Senator out as something special, whereas with the Omega they almost went the other way and tried to make them all look identical regardless of what was under the bonnet.

Kevin
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: Elite Pete on 04 January 2008, 10:32:43
Ive voted for the Omega, ive never had a Senator but if the pole was between an Omega and a Monza GSE I still would have voted for the Omega, as an everyday car its far better
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: Crazydad on 04 January 2008, 10:55:34
Quote
i have 2 Omega facelifts, but i still have a soft spot for the old Senator...

I did over 2,000 miles in 2 weeks in Senny in Europe this year, never missed a beat.

Cracking cars... the omega is far more refined at speed.
No you didnt ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: tunnie on 04 January 2008, 11:04:59
Quote
Quote
i have 2 Omega facelifts, but i still have a soft spot for the old Senator...

I did over 2,000 miles in 2 weeks in Senny in Europe this year, never missed a beat.

Cracking cars... the omega is far more refined at speed.
No you didnt ;D ;D ;D

oops
 ohh yeh. 2007 then  ;)
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: Crazydad on 04 January 2008, 11:36:14
Quote
Quote
Quote
i have 2 Omega facelifts, but i still have a soft spot for the old Senator...

I did over 2,000 miles in 2 weeks in Senny in Europe this year, never missed a beat.

Cracking cars... the omega is far more refined at speed.
No you didnt ;D ;D ;D

oops
 ohh yeh. 2007 then  ;)
Sorry, i know that STMO is the teacher, but i couldnt resist :y :y :y
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: brett1408 on 04 January 2008, 13:56:23
i've had both, omega's the better all round car, especially the spec, but i did have an ex-plod senator 24v manual, it was stupidly fast, as long as you never need a dual-mass-flywheel, they're great!! i love the senator interior though, it might not be as well equipted, but that lcd dash and curvy leather console, brilliant! and its real wood trim in senators! does anyone else think the elite grille on the mini facelift omegas was a hint back to the senator..................?
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 04 January 2008, 14:11:47
Having owned a few Omegas and driven a Senator around europe (although a 24V slush box).

The Omega is a generation ahead, better ride, better handling, better balance, more low down torque.......nicer interior (I dont like the 80's style interiors).

The bottom line is .....the Senator is old hat technology and it shows.
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: raximax on 04 January 2008, 17:00:23
i thought the omega would win hands down on this site but its closer than i thought it would be, so ill let it run a bit. it would be even closer if only pepole who owned both voted but hey its only a bit of fun. all comments are welcome..i must admit i like my omega and yes it is more modern and has more toys and yes it corners better but people still pull out infront of you which was a rare thing in the senny. i have thought if i had no car and was offerd one and i had to choose one it would be very hard but i must say the senny seems more apeeling now there is so few left, i think i have only seen one in about a year.
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: Omegatoy on 04 January 2008, 17:32:29
Senator manual every time, upgrade the suspension with spax adjustables and it wipes the floor with the Omega handling wise
yep Omega is better riding car but the front wishbones are set softer
so it would, having said all tht the Omega is the same chasssis as the senny so its just differnt settings on the suspension and better sound proofing on the Omega i think which makes the difference
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: Andy B on 04 January 2008, 17:33:41
Quote
...... i think i have only seen one in about a year.

with the exception of ABS meets, that's one more than me. I haven't seen one on the road in years.
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: sluggi on 05 January 2008, 00:24:43
Senator for me.Owned one for 8 years,never missed a beat :y
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: Kevin Wood on 05 January 2008, 00:26:32
Quote
Quote
...... i think i have only seen one in about a year.

with the exception of ABS meets, that's one more than me. I haven't seen one on the road in years.

I pass a couple of them almost daily on my commute to work 8-)

Kevin
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: TheBoy on 05 January 2008, 19:39:10
Omega for me.

Senators were good in there day, but that was an awful long time ago....
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: Del Boy on 05 January 2008, 19:43:14
Quote
Omega for me.

Senators were good in there day, but that was an awful long time ago....
Would totally agree
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: amigov6 on 05 January 2008, 19:59:44
Quote
Having owned a few Omegas and driven a Senator around europe (although a 24V slush box).

The Omega is a generation ahead, better ride, better handling, better balance, more low down torque.......nicer interior (I dont like the 80's style interiors).

The bottom line is .....the Senator is old hat technology and it shows.
:-/Evening Mark. I don't know how to say this without sounding gobby (i know ican be) but one day Omegas will be replaced with something & therefore become "old hat & outclassed" Will you no longer like them? I think you have a more practical view on things than me, i love "classic cars" despite their drawbacks, guess i'm a bit nostalgic.
   Hang on i'm just looking for my rose tinted specs!!! :-/
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: Admin on 05 January 2008, 20:15:10
I know what Mark is saying, he is an engineer (a proper one) and so will look at something from that perspective.

Me, I am not. I like cars that have "something" about them, hence my love of Alfa's :-[

The Senator is a car that is, for me, a classic. Much as I like Omegas, as much as they may be technically superior to a Senator, they will never have the same emotional attachment and will never become a classic.



Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: TheBoy on 05 January 2008, 20:21:08
Quote
I know what Mark is saying, he is an engineer (a proper one) and so will look at something from that perspective.

Me, I am not. I like cars that have "something" about them, hence my love of Alfa's :-[

The Senator is a car that is, for me, a classic. Much as I like Omegas, as much as they may be technically superior to a Senator, they will never have the same emotional attachment and will never become a classic.



I sort of agree with your view (though not about rustbuckets Senators) - I've still got a soft spot for my old Astra GTE that I had in the early 90s.  Awful handling (but predicatable), zero traction. But I liked it...  ...even though the (Honda engined) Rover 216 I replaced it with was faster, better handling, more comfortable, I preferred the GTE....
Title: Re: senator vs omega
Post by: raximax on 07 January 2008, 02:02:20
 quite a lot of interesting views, most of which i agree with. it looks like the people on here which have owned one likes them and no wonder, rip to the senny, the reson i started this thread i seen one on ebay for 295 but had no place to keep it as the wife would not give up her purple micra,,how sad is that. i would have let her drive the meega sometimes oh well its now gone divorce her is the next poll from me... ;D ;D ;D