Omega Owners Forum

Omega Help Area => Omega General Help => Topic started by: Pitchfork on 18 October 2010, 18:19:17

Title: Traktor EGR pipe
Post by: Pitchfork on 18 October 2010, 18:19:17
The stainless steel EGR pipe on the Traktor has just fractured - For the 3rd time in 7 years!!!
Does anyone else have similar problems with their BMW engined workhorse?
(Mine has done 160K miles in 14 years)
Title: Re: Traktor EGR pipe
Post by: Elite Pete on 18 October 2010, 18:40:51
I've done away with mine ;)
Title: Re: Traktor EGR pipe
Post by: TheBoy on 18 October 2010, 19:23:50
Have you got the middle clip on still?

Where did it break? Where it attaches to exhaust?
Title: Re: Traktor EGR pipe
Post by: Pitchfork on 18 October 2010, 19:30:54
Quote
Have you got the middle clip on still?

Where did it break? Where it attaches to exhaust?
Yes middle clip intact on all 3
The first went all around the end at the exhaust end
The second did the same but at the other end
Today's has multiple cracking at the first bend at the exhaust end
The first went around the mouth at the exhast end
Title: Re: Traktor EGR pipe
Post by: TheBoy on 18 October 2010, 19:34:06
Hmmm, what can I say, its BMW junk :P


If it keeps going, may be worth taking EP's advice  :-/
Title: Re: Traktor EGR pipe
Post by: Pitchfork on 18 October 2010, 19:36:18
Quote
Hmmm, what can I say, its BMW junk :P


If it keeps going, may be worth taking EP's advice  :-/
But surely getting rid of it increases polution & lowers MPG? It was added for a reason..........
Title: Re: Traktor EGR pipe
Post by: TheBoy on 18 October 2010, 19:46:27
Quote
Quote
Hmmm, what can I say, its BMW junk :P


If it keeps going, may be worth taking EP's advice  :-/
But surely getting rid of it increases polution & lowers MPG? It was added for a reason..........
I doubt any Omega owner cares that much about pollution, esp Tractor owners ;D

I only had to put 1 egr pipe on mine in the 2yrs i had it, the original had been bodged when I got it.  Got mine from scrappy
Title: Re: Traktor EGR pipe
Post by: Psychoca on 18 October 2010, 20:36:30
I have removed mine as well after 2nd went within 3 months...
Title: Re: Traktor EGR pipe
Post by: Kneepad on 18 October 2010, 21:07:29
Quote
Quote
Hmmm, what can I say, its BMW junk :P


If it keeps going, may be worth taking EP's advice  :-/
But surely getting rid of it increases polution & lowers MPG? It was added for a reason..........

I havn't noticed any increase in pollution or reduction in MPG since I blocked mine off.  ;)
Title: Re: Traktor EGR pipe
Post by: Evo on 19 October 2010, 06:04:55
Mine's done 180k in 14 years & no problem. Could it be defective engine mountings allowing too much movement?

You could check by blipping the accelerator with the bonnet open & seeing how much the engine rotates.
Title: Re: Traktor EGR pipe
Post by: Pitchfork on 19 October 2010, 08:37:55
Quote
Mine's done 180k in 14 years & no problem. Could it be defective engine mountings allowing too much movement?

You could check by blipping the accelerator with the bonnet open & seeing how much the engine rotates.
But everything is attached to engine at both ends so cannot see how this could be cause :question
Title: Re: Traktor EGR pipe
Post by: Evo on 19 October 2010, 14:12:25
My apologies ... you're right. The other end goes to the exhaust manifold. So not at all obvious as to why they should go. All I can think of is differential thermal expansion causes stress .. but doesn't seem likely.
Title: Re: Traktor EGR pipe
Post by: Pitchfork on 19 October 2010, 15:46:25
Quote
My apologies ... you're right. The other end goes to the exhaust manifold. So not at all obvious as to why they should go. All I can think of is differential thermal expansion causes stress .. but doesn't seem likely.
Aye..........you cannae change the laws of Physics!!
Title: Re: Traktor EGR pipe
Post by: Seth on 19 October 2010, 18:33:32
Have you had the auxiliary belt changed recently?
'Someone' may possibly have levered against it whilst refitting the tensioner damper bracket.

Just a thought .........  :D
Title: Re: Traktor EGR pipe
Post by: osealy on 19 October 2010, 20:47:25
Never had that problem. 4 TD's  c 250k mls , most on the one car was 145k (died of no hot start)
Title: Re: Traktor EGR pipe
Post by: Omegatoy on 21 October 2010, 20:10:57
Hmm
have you got vibration from the dmf? or the crankshaft pulley?
either of these could cause it to fracture with monotonous regularity, trouble with both is that the vibration creeps up on
you slowly and you never even notice it!!! engine mountings are a poss as it would vibrate against chassis and this could be transmitted to the egr pipe, as they all broke in different places it does point to it being a vibration issue? jm2pw :y