Omega Owners Forum

Chat Area => General Discussion Area => Topic started by: Varche on 27 February 2008, 10:04:01

Title: Speaker cone replacement on Household Hi Fi
Post by: Varche on 27 February 2008, 10:04:01
I got my ancient but much loved Technics Hi Fi separates out of store last night and connected it all up. It still works after over four years but I was dissapointed to find that the main speaker cones seem to have rotted away.

They are Mission 707's. I haven't got the money to replace them with new but thought they might be repairable . Has anyone done this? The speakers aren't a regular circular shape so I am guessing that they would have to come from "Mission" if they are still in business!

Any suggestions or info gratefully received.

varche  
Title: Re: Speaker cone replacement on Household Hi Fi
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 27 February 2008, 10:12:56
Mission are still in buisness and do provide spares but, they only make a finite number of spares and once they are gone no more are produced.
Be warey though because if you fit a new driver to one speaker, the other will then sound flat!
Title: Re: Speaker cone replacement on Household Hi Fi
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 27 February 2008, 10:14:48
These are listed as 707 repair kits...

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Foam-speaker-rings-surrounds-Mission-707-761-762-etc_W0QQitemZ120205617278QQihZ002QQcategoryZ112516QQrdZ1QQssPageNameZWD1VQQ_trksidZp1638.m118.l1247QQcmdZViewItem
Title: Re: Speaker cone replacement on Household Hi Fi
Post by: Varche on 27 February 2008, 10:25:32
Thanks Marks DTM.

I think they will do the job - the cones themselves are fine.

Funnily enough I have just done a search on Mission 707 on ebay and there is a guy selling a pair like mine with exactly the same problem. Bargain for someone with a state of the ark hi fi system with the above repair kit!!

I'll get some.

varche  
Title: Re: Speaker cone replacement on Household Hi Fi
Post by: Bo Bo on 27 February 2008, 10:47:07
Quote
Thanks Marks DTM.

I think they will do the job - the cones themselves are fine.

Funnily enough I have just done a search on Mission 707 on ebay and there is a guy selling a pair like mine with exactly the same problem. Bargain for someone with a state of the ark hi fi system with the above repair kit!!

I'll get some.

varche  
Not so new then  :D
Title: Re: Speaker cone replacement on Household Hi Fi
Post by: Martin_1962 on 27 February 2008, 11:03:30
I had similar with a pair of Castles - they rebuilt the drivers, the foam rots
Title: Re: Speaker cone replacement on Household Hi Fi
Post by: cem_devecioglu on 27 February 2008, 12:44:38
Even if repair kits or new paires cant be found ,

similiar size and likely same impedance cones will do the job..

I have built many speakers for myself and friends and in case of

change (they are damaged by the children gerenally)  with similiar

impedance I dont see important difference..(if not big difference in

quality)
Title: Re: Speaker cone replacement on Household Hi Fi
Post by: MaxV6 on 27 February 2008, 13:02:33
Quote
Even if repair kits or new paires cant be found ,

similiar size and likely same impedance cones will do the job..

I have built many speakers for myself and friends and in case of

change (they are damaged by the children gerenally)  with similiar

impedance I dont see important difference..(if not big difference in

quality)


Not all drivers are created equal, different frequency responses and efficiency ratings, not to mention whether they're designed to be used in a ported cabinet, or sealed cabinet, not to the mention power rating....

it's actually more likely that using "any old pair of drivers" will result in a speaker that doesn't sound remotely like it's designer intended, than any sort of happy accident "jackpot"

with regards to the peished 707's
Wembley loudspeakers, if they're still there, would be a good bet to get a decent repair  done ,..   haven't checked but their number was
02087434567

last time I used them.....


Title: Re: Speaker cone replacement on Household Hi Fi
Post by: cem_devecioglu on 27 February 2008, 13:08:51
Quote
Quote
Even if repair kits or new paires cant be found ,

similiar size and likely same impedance cones will do the job..

I have built many speakers for myself and friends and in case of

change (they are damaged by the children gerenally)  with similiar

impedance I dont see important difference..(if not big difference in

quality)


Not all drivers are created equal, different frequency responses and efficiency ratings, not to mention whether they're designed to be used in a ported cabinet, or sealed cabinet, not to the mention power rating....
it's actually more likely that using "any old pair of drivers" will result in a speaker that doesn't sound remotely like it's designer intended, than any sort of happy accident "jackpot"

with regards to the peished 707's
Wembley loudspeakers, if they're still there, would be a good bet to get a decent repair  done ,..   haven't checked but their number was
02087434567

last time I used them.....



Nowadays there are many kind of bass speakers , tweeters and mid range cones ..I think it will be easy to find one that suits the need..

and can be better also as it will have new technology..

ps: arrangement in cross over filter will give much better results..

Title: Re: Speaker cone replacement on Household Hi Fi
Post by: MaxV6 on 27 February 2008, 14:02:40
Quote
Quote
Quote
Even if repair kits or new paires cant be found ,

similiar size and likely same impedance cones will do the job..

I have built many speakers for myself and friends and in case of

change (they are damaged by the children gerenally)  with similiar

impedance I dont see important difference..(if not big difference in

quality)


Not all drivers are created equal, different frequency responses and efficiency ratings, not to mention whether they're designed to be used in a ported cabinet, or sealed cabinet, not to the mention power rating....
it's actually more likely that using "any old pair of drivers" will result in a speaker that doesn't sound remotely like it's designer intended, than any sort of happy accident "jackpot"

with regards to the peished 707's
Wembley loudspeakers, if they're still there, would be a good bet to get a decent repair  done ,..   haven't checked but their number was
02087434567

last time I used them.....



Nowadays there are many kind of bass speakers , tweeters and mid range cones ..I think it will be easy to find one that suits the need..

and can be better also as it will have new technology..

ps: arrangement in cross over filter will give much better results..


I could list several thousand different drivers....

"easy to find"

not unless you know what the numbers associated with each one in terms of it's specification actually mean...   and most people definitely don't....

(I'm an audio engineer by trade.... so it's my little corner of complete geekdom , but my excuse is it's my job....    :y)


Oh, and new doesn't automatically mean better, often it's just different....

the essential physics of building a driver hasn't changed...  only some of the materials...   the core technology is identical to the way it's always been....    Magnet + coil + variable current = movement.



Title: Re: Speaker cone replacement on Household Hi Fi
Post by: Marks DTM Calib on 27 February 2008, 14:23:34
Quote
Even if repair kits or new paires cant be found ,

similiar size and likely same impedance cones will do the job..

I have built many speakers for myself and friends and in case of

change (they are damaged by the children gerenally)  with similiar

impedance I dont see important difference..(if not big difference in

quality)

Speaker design is a detailed process and very itterative...

You start by deciding on size, port/no port, number of ports, application etc as per your target market.....you then select a driver to suit the target design.....more often than not you will then tweak the cabinet design or even the driver to enhance things.....

Getting a good match for a main stream setup by the likes of Mission will be a tough process, your only real chance is a new driver from Mission directly (I bet its been tweaked so will be a special)

But, here budget is a key consideration and hence the repair kits (which are actualy pretty simple and reliable to fit) although these will probably have a different compliance to the origianls!
Title: Re: Speaker cone replacement on Household Hi Fi
Post by: cem_devecioglu on 27 February 2008, 15:04:07
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Even if repair kits or new paires cant be found ,

similiar size and likely same impedance cones will do the job..

I have built many speakers for myself and friends and in case of

change (they are damaged by the children gerenally)  with similiar

impedance I dont see important difference..(if not big difference in

quality)


Not all drivers are created equal, different frequency responses and efficiency ratings, not to mention whether they're designed to be used in a ported cabinet, or sealed cabinet, not to the mention power rating....
it's actually more likely that using "any old pair of drivers" will result in a speaker that doesn't sound remotely like it's designer intended, than any sort of happy accident "jackpot"

with regards to the peished 707's
Wembley loudspeakers, if they're still there, would be a good bet to get a decent repair  done ,..   haven't checked but their number was
02087434567

last time I used them.....



Nowadays there are many kind of bass speakers , tweeters and mid range cones ..I think it will be easy to find one that suits the need..

and can be better also as it will have new technology..

ps: arrangement in cross over filter will give much better results..


I could list several thousand different drivers....

"easy to find"

not unless you know what the numbers associated with each one in terms of it's specification actually mean...   and most people definitely don't....

(I'm an audio engineer by trade.... so it's my little corner of complete geekdom , but my excuse is it's my job....    :y)


Oh, and new doesn't automatically mean better, often it's just different....

the essential physics of building a driver hasn't changed...  only some of the materials...   the core technology is identical to the way it's always been....    Magnet + coil + variable current = movement.





Not every music listener is audio enginner and I believe wont be sensitive as some  ;D
Title: Re: Speaker cone replacement on Household Hi Fi
Post by: cem_devecioglu on 27 February 2008, 15:08:44
Quote
Quote
Even if repair kits or new paires cant be found ,

similiar size and likely same impedance cones will do the job..

I have built many speakers for myself and friends and in case of

change (they are damaged by the children gerenally)  with similiar

impedance I dont see important difference..(if not big difference in

quality)

Speaker design is a detailed process and very itterative...

You start by deciding on size, port/no port, number of ports, application etc as per your target market.....you then select a driver to suit the target design.....more often than not you will then tweak the cabinet design or even the driver to enhance things.....

Getting a good match for a main stream setup by the likes of Mission will be a tough process, your only real chance is a new driver from Mission directly (I bet its been tweaked so will be a special)

But, here budget is a key consideration and hence the repair kits (which are actualy pretty simple and reliable to fit) although these will probably have a different compliance to the origianls!


I said "if repair kits or similiar not available"..

and by the way I dont think these speakers are magic or come

down from the sky.. I see many expensive speakers (really good

brand) beaten by simple set ups.. :y

Title: Re: Speaker cone replacement on Household Hi Fi
Post by: cem_devecioglu on 27 February 2008, 15:31:42
here is a funny example  ;D

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mPZ9UsOr-JY



http://www.metacafe.com/watch/719200/homemade_speakers
Title: Re: Speaker cone replacement on Household Hi Fi
Post by: wakeyomega on 27 February 2008, 17:14:53
personally I tend to agree with Cem - if only my 57 year old ears where any where near as good as the specs of some expensive speakers it may be worth the money!  ;D