Main Menu

Heliocoil

Started by jimbobmccoy, 14 August 2012, 21:18:45

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Marks DTM Calib

No loctite used on the sump plug.

Never had one unscrew either, its probably very dependent on the quality of the helicoil.

Either way a helicoil is more than strong enough (much stronger than the original tapped casting), much cheaper to do, can be done in situ and is reliable.


Andy H

Getting a good clean dry thread seems to be the key, followed by turning the tool backwards to get the coil to bite before snapping the tang off neatly.

I imagine that the tang will drop down in the plug hole if the supplied tool is used to snap it off  :-\ (so thin nosed pliers for the last bit then.....)
"Deja Moo - The feeling that you've heard this bull somewhere before."

Andy B

Quote from: Marks DTM Calib on 17 August 2012, 12:31:15....
can be done in situ and is reliable.

and soooooo reliable, that Time Sert do an over size kit for use after a Helicoil has failed ......
QuoteNOTE: If the hole was previously REPAIRED with Helicoil or save-a-thread style insert.
Use our BIG-SERT for oversized spark plug repairs click here:
http://www.timesert.com/html/sparkplug.html


http://www.timesert.com/html/bigsert_sparkplug.html  ::)  ::)

If a Helicoil can be done in situ, I can't see any reason why a Time Sert shouldn't be done in situ either  ??? ??? ???

hoody

If people are afraid of Helicoils may i suggest they stay away from airplanes ;)

Andy B

Quote from: hoody on 17 August 2012, 20:42:42
If people are afraid of Helicoils may i suggest they stay away from airplanes ;)

never said I was afraid ... just said that there's better on the market now. ie a one piece solid thread insert rather than a coil of thread that's able to unwind from the hole it's threaded into.  :y

feeutfo

Does the success of one of these depend on the amount, or qulaity, of material left to screw it into...?

Rather than the quality of whatever product is used..? :-\

Andy B

Quote from: chrisgixer on 17 August 2012, 21:23:35
Does the success of one of these  .....


Helicoil or Time sert  .........  :-\ :-\ :-\

jibberwobble

If helicoils are fitted correctly they should be good. Most of the problematic ones I've dealt with were not seated properly in the first place. IMHO if you get a helicoil put in by your average mechanic that rarely uses these things you have a 50/50 chance of it being duff.

The little helicoils can be a right PITA sometimes and some batches are worse than others. Spark plug size ones should be fine though.

Having said that, given the choice I'd still choose a timesert/keensert or similar due to ease of use. Depends what available I guess.

The thread will need tapping out to a larger size anyway so the thread quality should be good.

jimbobmccoy

So, I got the car back last Saturday.

Got a garage to do it iN the end, as the price was initially suggested as £150-ish, ended up been £100 more.......was not impressed, but apparently the inlet manifold had to come off and some modification of tools was required.......to be fair I can see this being true, it is a deep plug and an awkward spot.

Oddly any garage I spoke to I asked about a helicoil and they all replied that they wouldn't use that, that they'd use a different insert, likes I guess either experience, or pub science has lead them to lean towards a solid insert.
Options suggested where either snap on version of time sert, or time sert itself.  In the end a time sert went in.

Car is all good now, and defo up on power........it goes to show how a gradually declining part can affect performance drastically without being too noticeable, if it's a slow decline.

Andy B

Quote from: jimbobmccoy on 21 August 2012, 21:53:19
So, I got the car back last Saturday.

Got a garage to do it iN the end, as the price was initially suggested as £150-ish, ended up been £100 more.......was not impressed, but apparently the inlet manifold had to come off and some modification of tools was required.......to be fair I can see this being true, it is a deep plug and an awkward spot.

Oddly any garage I spoke to I asked about a helicoil and they all replied that they wouldn't use that, that they'd use a different insert, likes I guess either experience, or pub science has lead them to lean towards a solid insert.
Options suggested where either snap on version of time sert, or time sert itself.  In the end a time sert went in.

Car is all good now, and defo up on power........it goes to show how a gradually declining part can affect performance drastically without being too noticeable, if it's a slow decline.

Glad you're sorted. I know hind sight is a wonderful thing, but £250 would've got you A N Other head fitted  :-\ :-\