Ok, I'm biased, I've never used the later paper jobbie, but just ignoring that a VOF93 costs £1 on tradeclub, I suppose the idea that the older type is superior probably comes from those times/people that have literally had to smash the old one off. Given that you do that, then have to blag a lift from a mate to go to the Stealer for a replacement housing (no idea what they are, but I imagine not pence) then fit the new housing, does seem a backward stem when compared with the 'destroy the old filter when removing, simply plop the new on on hand-tight, have a cuppa' method.
I suppose if you do your own servicing and the housing comes off fine the first time you change the oil, and torque it up properly, there's no reason to suppose that it won't come undone again for the next ten years. Perhaps the idea (or myth?) that the earlier VOF 93 is the superior is from previous owners/garages tightening it too far, thus making removal without destruction impossible.
Does anyone have experience of personally tightening their later-type up one year, then come next oilchange it's stuffed?