Another piece of history...

Started by BazaJT, 09 February 2019, 18:50:24

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Doctor Gollum

Had she managed another twelve hours undetected she would have been well within air cover range and pretty much home free and we would not have been so lucky.

Damaging the fuel transfer systems and flooding the bow was pure luck for us as it slowed her down enough to track. The torpedo jamming the rudder was shear chance and the icing on the cake. Had neither thing happened, then Prinz Eugen wouldn't have gone straight back the the fjords to wait for us to sink it... The rest is, as they say, history.
Onanists always think outside the box.

Lizzie Zoom

Quote from: Doctor Gollum on 11 February 2019, 20:09:47
Had she managed another twelve hours undetected she would have been well within air cover range and pretty much home free and we would not have been so lucky.

Damaging the fuel transfer systems and flooding the bow was pure luck for us as it slowed her down enough to track. The torpedo jamming the rudder was shear chance and the icing on the cake. Had neither thing happened, then Prinz Eugen wouldn't have gone straight back the the fjords to wait for us to sink it... The rest is, as they say, history.

She was within the range of the Luftwaffe, especially their Condor maritime bombers, but Hitler had decided she was a lost cause.  Nothing was down to just "luck", as a lot of British effort had eventually brought the Bismark to her fate, as happens in war. The plucky pilots of the Swordfish torpedo aircraft brought about the hit on her through tremendous bravery, and the "lucky" fact if you like that they were in very slow moving aircraft that the German gunners found difficult to train their modern anti-aircraft guns on.

In fact so much of the eventual victory over Nazi Germany could be simply put down to "luck" and the stupidity of Hitler, but the taking advantage of all those "lucky" moments is what war is often about. It is that the brings Victory, but always at an horric cost, which I am sure the dead of war would not consider as being down to just luck ;)

Doctor Gollum

Luck works both ways ;)

Not to undermine the sacrifices made by those who gave, and often lost, everything... a bit more fog/ a bit less wind/ a misread bearing or instruction and a battle is won/lost/averted.

The best laid plans of mice and men and all that...
Onanists always think outside the box.

Lizzie Zoom

Quote from: Doctor Gollum on 11 February 2019, 20:33:18
Luck works both ways ;)

Not to undermine the sacrifices made by those who gave, and often lost, everything... a bit more fog/ a bit less wind/ a misread bearing or instruction and a battle is won/lost/averted.

The best laid plans of mice and men and all that...

Exactly right! :y :y