On BBC-HD

Probably not worthwhile in the case of TG. More storage space on my tiny (1Tb) disk. Fortunately:
a) MCE is a bloody first class upscaler
b) I have a bigger disk on order 
You cannot recreate missing information.
I have done some digging around and supposedly the PS3 is a good upscaler, so is my TV - anyway DVD and SDTV is noticably worse than BR and BBC-HD
Oh and my DVD player via top end RGB looks no different to PS3 upscaling, I did try component for DVD, looked slightly different - no better no worse.
You're right, no upscaler is perfect. However, MCE is significantly better than PS3, which itself is (marginally) better than W Series Sony.
I have Casino Royale in normal DVD format, and (being a bond fan) have the BRD version. The way MCE deals with it, you'd be hard pressed to tell them apart unless side-by-side. I have set this test to a few people, and whilst everyone has got the test right, they were impressed with upscale

Freesat-HD (and Sky-HD) is only 720P, and by time its heavily compressed, isn't massively better than normal DVD
