Had two Toyotas. Both bomb proof even though red lined every day I had them. Uncanny feeling of being attached to horizon by huge elastic band.
No faults. Total reliability. Only normal service items. First one I had did 160K on original discs & exhaust and was still going strong when i sold it. (Wish I'd kept it) Auto boxes advanced. When I look back Main dealer servicing expensive though, but standards high.
Embarrasingly my friends 20 year old Carina sounds better and runs smoother than my 2.2 Omega. (vauxhall told me engine noise was "normal for that model @ 10,000 miles :-?)
As others have already said, I would avoid imports even if very cheap as surprising amount of parts different and often difficult to source. Insurance more expensive. Service history in japanese and almost impossible to confirm. Resale more difficult.
Celica you mention looks superb on the right rims, only drawback if pushing on is front wheel drive. Engine is sweet though, jointly developed with Yamaha.