News:

Please check the Forum Guidelines at the top of the Newbie section

Main Menu

possible problem with Bilstein b4

Started by feeutfo, 14 February 2013, 10:05:09

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

feeutfo

This a Bilstein b4 front shock "spring cup" as I call it. The rub line above the chisel shows where its been rubbing on the outboard vertical face of the wheel arch liner. Think I found the hollow clonk as the suspension compresses.  :(  :)


feeutfo

Oh, and its the same both side btw.

05omegav6

Weak springs/soft shocks/too little camber :-\

Unlikely to be the third one, but how many miles have the struts/springs done?

feeutfo

Quote from: ex taxi al on 14 February 2013, 10:26:07
Weak springs/soft shocks/too little camber :-\

Unlikely to be the third one, but how many miles have the struts/springs done?
They where both new, about 18months ago. Set up is as wim.

I need to measure the distance from the outboard edge of the spring cup to the shock shaft and compare with oe.

I suspect the Billy's spring cup is too wide. :-\

05omegav6

That would suggest that they're not exactly compatible with the Irmy/OE springs :-\

feeutfo

Quote from: ex taxi al on 14 February 2013, 12:21:38
That would suggest that they're not exactly compatible with the Irmy/OE springs :-\
Mmmmno, don't think its that, the rim doesn't support the spring, there's a moulded rubber pad shaped to the sping base that supports the springs position.

I think the rim is there if the spring brakes so it can't skew sideways. :-\

feeutfo

Other possible though is that the top mount has collapsed or is faulty.

I'd be surprised though. 

05omegav6

Quote from: chrisgixer on 14 February 2013, 12:44:05
Other possible though is that the top mount has collapsed or is faulty.

I'd be surprised though. 

IME, that would show through the steering and general handling. Any play in the leg when it's up in the air :-\

TheBoy

A fair few use B4s, so would have thought this would have shown up before?

Unless others do not use the car to its capability...
Grumpy old man

feeutfo

Quote from: TheBoy on 14 February 2013, 17:25:38
A fair few use B4s, so would have thought this would have shown up before?

Unless others do not use the car to its capability...
remember that knock/thump over the speed bumps in Brackley...?

TheBoy

Quote from: chrisgixer on 14 February 2013, 18:46:24
Quote from: TheBoy on 14 February 2013, 17:25:38
A fair few use B4s, so would have thought this would have shown up before?

Unless others do not use the car to its capability...
remember that knock/thump over the speed bumps in Brackley...?
A very 'dull' knock, iirc?
Grumpy old man

feeutfo

Quote from: TheBoy on 14 February 2013, 18:50:59
Quote from: chrisgixer on 14 February 2013, 18:46:24
Quote from: TheBoy on 14 February 2013, 17:25:38
A fair few use B4s, so would have thought this would have shown up before?

Unless others do not use the car to its capability...
remember that knock/thump over the speed bumps in Brackley...?
A very 'dull' knock, iirc?
thats the one, dull because its plastic

feeutfo

the suspension only needs to compress an inch for the spring cup to meet the wheel arch liner

05omegav6