"if i give out hard punishment i'm in wrong by ann for doing so"
the way i see it mate, the first thing you've got to do is sit down with your lass and sort out a plan that you both agree on and stick to it or as kid get older, she will play one off against the other and belive me, that is when the fun starts !!
kids at that age will always push the boundries !
what are her school friends like ?
is she playing up just to impress somebody at school ?
i had alot of problems with a our lasses lad who i brought up as my own from the age of 3. ( he's now 20 ).
now im a "old school" parent. im my kids best friend or there worst enemy and quite happy to administer a slap when nesersary but only as a last resort and only when i know the kid understands why they are getting it but it soon got to the point where i would kick off and then 30 miniutes later, our lass would go and give him a cuddle behind my back !
end result, he hates me and thinks im the most evil tw*t on the planet

which at the time actualy split this family up for 6 months as i could'nt take anymore shit

something else to consider. if she is anything like my lad, ( not the other little sh*t i tried to bring up ) then pushing her 2 hard might push her into her "shell"
just remember this mate, NOBODY has ever wrote a book on bringing kids up that is'nt 'dangle berries', you both just have to do the parenting thing YOUR way and if in 20 years time she has turned out ok then you BOTH did it right
